In remembrance, now and always

Deputy Rex A. Emrick
Pickaway County Sheriff’s Office
End of watch: Jan. 26, 2021

Rex Emrick devoted nearly 47 years to law enforcement and was still working as a detective when COVID-19 claimed his life in January 2021, five weeks shy of his 70th birthday.

“Rex was such a tough individual, an old farm boy,” Capt. John Strawser said. “During much of the time I worked with him in the Detective Bureau, he was battling cancer off and on. In fact, he beat it twice. So it blew my mind that COVID took his life.”

Emrick spent all but 18 months of his career with the Pickaway County Sheriff’s Office, serving under three sheriffs – Dwight Radcliff, the nation’s longest-serving sheriff and to whom Emrick felt an overriding sense of gratitude and loyalty; Radcliff’s son, Robert; and Matthew Hafey, who took office shortly before Emrick’s death.

Along the way, law enforcement organizations and civic groups formally recognized Detective Emrick’s numerous accomplishments with awards and citations. At the same time, crime victims, citizens, prosecutors, judges and his fellow officers regularly offered their thanks for a job well done.

True to form, though, he always deflected attention from himself, instead directing it to his law enforcement colleagues.

“It took all of us to bring these cases to a successful conclusion,” Detective Emrick told the Circleville Herald in an interview a year before he died. “I don’t feel that I’m anything special. In a small department, it takes everyone to make successful arrests.”

Emrick began his law enforcement career in 1974 as a part-time police officer with the village of Mount Sterling. In January 1976, he moved to the Pickaway County Sheriff’s Office, where he initially served as a dispatcher and later in a special-duty assignment as an undercover deputy investigating illegal drug trafficking.

He was subsequently assigned to the jail as a corrections officer before being transferred to the Road Division as a patrol deputy.

In 1994, he was promoted to the Detective Bureau, where he remained until the end of his watch. He was the lead investigator on several major cases, including homicide and child-sex-abuse cases. He also was assigned to work on cases stemming from the Ohio Organized Crime Investigations Commission, an arm of the Ohio Attorney General’s Office. He retired from the sheriff’s office only to return months later.

Over the course of his long career, Emrick developed countless connections throughout Ohio.

“No matter where we went in the state, people knew him,” said Sgt. Tracy Andrews, who worked in the Detective Bureau with him. “He touched so many lives, directly and indirectly.”

Detective Emrick is survived by his wife of 42 years, Becky; their son, Ryan, and daughter, Ranelle; four grandchildren – Taylor, Cahli, Kinleigh and Pacey; his sister, Suzanne, and brother, Phil; and many other family members.

Andrews said his colleague was “devoted to his grandchildren, spent a lot of time with them, and would do anything and everything for them.”

Although Detective Emrick tried to shun attention in life, it continues to follow him posthumously.

State Rep. Brian Stewart (R-Ashville) introduced legislation earlier this year to designate a portion of State Route 56 in Pickaway County as the “Detective Rex Emrick Memorial Highway.”

“He was a strong leader and faithful public servant in our community,” Stewart said. “Renaming this road in his honor is just a small way to pay tribute to his legacy of service.”

Corrections Lt. David W. Reynolds
Butler County Sheriff's Office
End of watch: Sept. 30, 2021

Some people make it their mission to generate light, no matter the circumstances.

Corrections Lt. David Reynolds was one of them, always smiling, laughing and upbeat – a positive inspiration day after day, according to his friends.

When he said he was “living a dream” – and he said it often – his words reflected the gratitude of a man who counted his blessings. Chief among those blessings was his family, and anyone who knew Lt. Reynolds even marginally soon came to realize that.

Lt. Reynolds, 58, died in September 2021 of complications resulting from COVID-19, which he contracted while working at the Butler County Jail.

“Dave used to remind us how important our families and personal lives were,” said Sgt. Melinda Weddle, who worked with Reynolds in the Corrections Division of the Butler County Sheriff’s Office. “Regardless of what happened at work, he’d remind us that ‘the building will still be standing’ long after we are gone, and that our families are what are really important. He was our rock, our counselor and our hero.”

In 1984, Reynolds married the love of his life, Becky Williams, whom he had met in church and later attended college with and worked with at the sheriff’s office. Together they raised three sons in a home filled with love and laughs – one that always made room for dogs.

“Our basset hound Bea had a particular hold on David,” Becky said.

David Reynolds joined the Butler County Sheriff’s Office in 2001 as a corrections officer and rose through the ranks to lieutenant. In addition, he was a former member of the Hanover Township Fire Department.

An ordained Baptist minister, he served as pastor at various churches through the years and officiated at the weddings of his two oldest sons and several co-workers.

Becky Reynolds said her husband lived his faith at work.

“Working in the jail was a ministry to him,” she said. “He treated inmates with the same respect he gave everyone else. In fact, it wasn’t unusual for us to run into former inmates at the grocery store or someplace else in town, and they’d stop David to tell him how they had gone through rehab or found a job and were turning their lives around. And David always encouraged them and told them how proud he was of them.”

Colleagues said young officers sought Reynolds’ advice, whether for career or personal matters, knowing that they could count on him for a sympathetic ear.

Nick Fisher, who was a corrections captain and the jail warden before his retirement, said Reynolds was one of the most liked and trusted men within the Corrections Division.

“David was loved by everybody,” Fisher said. “He was a boots-on-the-ground type of guy who worked his way up. He was not only a manager and a leader; he was a friend and a spiritual leader to a lot of staff members. He took a lot of people under his wing.”

Lt. Rob Clendenin said Lt. Reynolds “was a religious man who seldom let a curse word fly. But if he did, look out! He cared about his co-workers and was always there to give them the perfect pep talk. He was greatly respected and loved by many.”

In addition to his wife, Lt. Reynolds is survived by his three sons and two daughters-in-law – Andrew and his wife, Whitney; Nathan and his wife, Jordan; and Jacob. He also was a proud grandfather – “Papaw” – to Atticus and Luca, and a loving brother to Denise, Sharon and Keith.

Lt. Reynolds’ death devastated the sheriff’s office and compounded the grief it was already dealing with after the loss three weeks earlier of Deputy Craig Mills.

Reynolds and Mills were among more than 400 U.S. law enforcement officers who died in 2021 of COVID complications, the leading cause of line-of-duty deaths that year, according to the National Law Enforcement Officers Memorial Fund.

Officer Jacob Derbin
Euclid Police Department
End of watch: May 11, 2024

As a kid, Jacob Derbin looked up to his grandfather Dennis Derbin and longed to be a cop just like him. After giving his life in the line of duty, Derbin now lies next to his idol at St. Mary’s Cemetery in Cuyahoga Heights.

The Euclid police officer was fatally shot in an ambush while answering an aggravated menacing and domestic disturbance call on the night of May 11, 2024 – Mother’s Day weekend. The 23-year-old had joined the department just 10 months earlier, often working the same shift as his father, Officer Vince Trusso.

“Officer Jacob Derbin exemplified courage and dedication,” Euclid Police Chief Scott Meyer said. “He embodied the spirit of duty and compassion. In a world that often needs healing, Officer Derbin led with integrity and strength, showing us the power of selfless service."

Growing up, Jacob Derbin knew he was destined for public service. It ran in his family, after all.

Both grandfathers had been officers, and his mother, Dawn, served 15 years as a firefighter/paramedic in the Brooklyn Heights Fire Department before becoming a nurse. Likewise, two of his uncles were cops, as was his dad, a K-9 officer with Euclid PD – the same career path Jacob wanted to follow.

After graduating from Cuyahoga Heights High School and simultaneously earning his firefighter and EMT certification at Cuyahoga Valley Career Center, Derbin joined the Ohio Army National Guard and served a tour of duty in Kuwait and Iraq. During that deployment, unfortunately, his grandfather died suddenly.

Derbin earned 15 medals and ribbons during his military service. He graduated from the Kent State University Police Academy in February 2023 and was sworn in five months later as an officer with the Euclid PD. All the while, he and his fiancée, Liv Wuebker, were counting down the days to their wedding the following July.

“His life was like a fairy tale,” his mother said.

On May 11, Officer Derbin and two other officers responded to a 911 call from a woman who said she was at her grandmother’s house and that her ex-boyfriend, her child’s father, was lurking outside and texting that he was going to kill her. When the officers arrived, the woman told them that the man was probably hiding nearby and asked them to check the backyard.

When they did, the man ambushed Officer Derbin and fled. He was tracked to Shaker Heights the next day and found dead after a lengthy standoff.

Officer Derbin was known for his big smile and outgoing personality. He was a standout center on the Cuyahoga Heights football team that played for the state championship in 2017 and also participated in wrestling and track.

To honor her son, Dawn Derbin established the Officer Jacob Derbin Foundation, which will award $1,400 a year to a senior at Cuyahoga Heights High.

“Jacob was a gentle, kind and amazing young man,” she said. “He was a rare human being, a born hero.”

It’s a source of comfort, she said, knowing that Jacob and his grandfather are together in heaven: “I know my dad’s up there holding him until I can get there myself.”

In addition to his mother and father, Officer Derbin is survived by siblings Toran Cline, Gavin Cline, Dominic Trusso and Francesca Trusso; his grandmothers; and other family members.

Officer Jamieson R. Ritter
Cleveland Division of Police
End of watch: July 4, 2024

In April 2024, Cleveland Police Officer Jamieson Ritter and his partner saved a man who had jumped into the Cuyahoga River. A month later, they saved a man who had been shot multiple times by an unknown assailant.

In June, the Cleveland Police Foundation honored their heroism by naming them Patrol Officers of the Month.

Tragically, just weeks later, Officer Ritter was killed. Early on the morning of July 4, Officer Ritter and several other officers went to a house on E. 80th Street in the Hough neighborhood to serve an arrest warrant on a man wanted for stealing a gun from his grandmother and shooting her in the back of the head days earlier.

As the suspect attempted to flee by bike, he fired four shots before officers subdued him. One shot hit Officer Ritter, who was rushed to University Hospitals, where he was pronounced dead. He was 27.

The suspect was arrested and indicted on murder charges but was later determined to be incompetent to stand trial.

Ritter grew up and went to high school at McQuaid Jesuit in suburban Rochester, New York. He went to Syracuse University on a Reserve Officer Training Corps (ROTC) scholarship, graduated in 2019, and was commissioned as a second lieutenant in the Army National Guard. He joined the Cleveland Division of Police in November 2020 and was assigned to the city’s 3rd District.

In 2022, he was deployed to Syria with his Ohio Army National Guard unit, the 134th Field Artillery Regiment, earning a combat action badge for engaging the enemy. In October 2023, he returned to the 3rd District with the Cleveland Police.

Police Chief Dorothy “Annie” Todd said Ritter grew up with a profound desire to serve his country and community.

“His compassion for those in need and his relentless pursuit of justice were evident in every action he took,” she said. “Jamieson was not just an officer; he was a guardian of our community, a beacon of hope and a symbol of strength.”

Ohio Attorney General Dave Yost called Ritter a “selfless hero” and noted the tragic irony of his dying on July 4: “The loss of an officer on a day when we celebrate the many freedoms of our country is a cruel reminder of the price paid by those who have made the ultimate sacrifice to keep our communities safe.”

Officer Ritter’s murder occurred amid his plans to move back to Rochester. His parents, Karen and Jonathan, said their son was applying to the Rochester Police Department and had signed up to take the exam for the New York State Police.

“We were looking at homes to purchase for him,” Karen Ritter said. “He had decided he was ready to come home and be with his family again. It was a dream come true.”

In addition to his parents, Officer Ritter is survived by his brother, Army Maj. Jonathan Ritter; two sisters, Alysia and Angelica; two nieces, Ryleigh and Sloane; and a nephew, Wyatt.

The Jamieson Ritter Foundation was established soon after his death by friends and family. It will award an annual public-service scholarship to a graduating senior at McQuaid Jesuit High.

Deputy Marshal John E. Sellers
Shelby Police Department
End of watch: June 4, 1897

John Elliott Sellers was born in 1845 in or near Chambersburg, Pennsylvania, and came to settle 20 years later in the village of Shelby, Ohio.

In June 1897, during his first year with the Shelby Police Department, Deputy Marshal Sellers was fatally shot in the abdomen while attempting to remove a vagrant from the town’s train depot. He was 51. The vagrant was convicted of manslaughter and sentenced to 20 years in prison.

The obituary that ran in the Shelby News a week after Deputy Marshal Seller’s death described him as “a kind husband and father, pleasing in his social relations, enterprising and widely known as a citizen. This community mourns over the tragic deed that so cruelly destroyed the life of the devoted husband and father.”

Sellers went to school until age 16 and learned the cabinet-making trade before moving to Shelby in 1865. He joined the Shelby Reformed Church in 1866 and two years later married Susannah Laser. At the time of his death, they were raising a son and two daughters.

Most of what is known about Sellers involves his service in the Civil War. According to his obituary, he enlisted in the Union Army three times with varying Pennsylvania infantry and cavalry regiments – the first for three months, the second for nine months, and the third for three years.

He fought at South Mountain, Antietam, Fredericksburg and Chancellorsville. Later in the war, he suffered serious wounds to his right ear and neck during a battle for control of the Southside Railroad in the Shenandoah Valley. He was sent to a hospital in Washington to recover, then transferred to Philadelphia, where he was discharged in June 1865.

It isn’t known specifically why Sellers moved from Pennsylvania to Ohio, but the fate of his hometown surely played a part in the decision. Chambersburg was only 13 miles north of the Maryland border, which made up part of the Mason-Dixon Line separating the Union states from the Confederacy. Confederate forces occupied the town three times, the last time burning it to the ground.

Game Warden Harvey L. Monbeck
Ohio Department of Natural Resources, Division of Wildlife
End of watch: Nov. 5, 1927

Game Warden Harvey Monbeck was killed in a vehicle crash on the Dixie Highway, near Stroop Road, in Moraine, Ohio. He was 61.

He was en route to the state game reserves south of Dayton to investigate reports of poaching when his car collided with a bread truck. Game Warden Monbeck was killed instantly in the crash.

He had served as the state game warden in Montgomery County for eight years. He was survived by his wife, daughter, and five sons.

Patrolman Mark U. Heinl
St. Henry Police Department
End of watch: Nov. 28, 2020

Mark Heinl was a cop at heart, but much more. He loved the people of his community and served them well in many ways. And they loved him back.

“I used to say Mark could talk to a brick wall – he could talk to anybody,” said his wife, Sandy. “He knew everybody in Mercer County, and I’m not kidding when I say everybody.”

Heinl retired as a captain from the Mercer County Sheriff’s Office in 2016 but was soon back in uniform as a patrolman for the St. Henry Police Department. He contracted COVID in late October 2020 and died a month later, two days after Thanksgiving. He was 60.

Heinl regularly lent his time and talent to his community.

He volunteered with the Coldwater Fire Department, Coldwater Emergency Medical Services, and Mercer County Emergency Response Volunteers. He was active in the Catholic charitable organization Knights of St. John; the Maria Stein Country Fest Committee; and the Mercer County Sheriff’s Office Explorer program, which gave a teenage Heinl his introduction to policing.

He also served as a governor for the USS Gambier Bay Committee, an organization founded by his father to honor 147 fellow crewmen who died when the Japanese sunk their aircraft carrier in World War II.

After his retirement, in addition to his duties with the St. Henry PD, Heinl worked part-time at the Darke County Sheriff’s Office and drove a bus for Coldwater, Marion Local and St. Henry schools.

From a young age, he wanted to be cop. As soon as he could, he joined the Explorers at the Mercer County Sheriff’s Office, and later volunteered with the reserve unit there.

“People who knew him as a boy say it blew their mind that he ended up in law enforcement because he was so ornery,” Sandy said. “They say if there was some kind of mischief going on, Mark was usually part of it.”

Sandy met Mark at a high-school football game where he was working as a reserve deputy. Her younger sister, also an Explorer at the sheriff’s office, introduced them.

As it happened, another family connection also would play a role in their future romance and ensuing 36-year marriage: Sandy’s father was a captain at the sheriff’s office.

“It was all good,” she said. “My dad really liked Mark and gave him permission to date me.” The values that her husband lived by impacted others.

“He always said, ‘Treat people how you want to be treated,’ ” Sandy said. “And I know he did that to everybody. There were times when we’d be out in public, and someone would come up and say, ‘Hi, Capt. Heinl.’ When I’d ask later who the friendly stranger was, he’d tell me the guy was a former inmate he knew from his time working in the jail.”

Another favorite life lesson – work for things you believe in – took deep root in his family.

“He taught us to decide what’s important and to support it," daughter Ashlee Heinl-Botkin said. To that end, his family – including a son and daughter-in-law with the Mercer County Sheriff’s Office and a son with the Columbus Division of Police – started the Mark Heinl Law Enforcement Scholarship Fund. The fund has provided tuition for three cadets – one per year – to attend the Wright State Lake Campus Police Academy.

Heinl spent the first years of his law enforcement career with the Minster Police Department before moving to Coldwater in 1989 as a patrolman. He later returned to the Mercer County Sheriff’s Office, where he steadily rose to captain. In 1998, he received the Buckeye State Sheriffs’ Association Medal of Honor and the Celina Mercer County Chamber Outstanding Achievement Award for saving a woman from drowning.

In addition to his wife and daughter Ashlee (Matthew), Heinl is survived by sons Mark (Donita) Heinl II and Spencer (Rachel) Heinl; daughter Cassandra (Tyler) Helentjaris; 10 grandchildren; and a brother, John, and his wife, Sheila.

Officer Gerald F. Lynch
Mentor Police Department
End of watch: Oct. 3, 2021

From high-school graduation in 1983 until his untimely death in October 2021, Gerry Lynch did the work he loved – law enforcement. And for nearly all that time, he was doubly lucky to be married to the woman of his dreams, Teri-Jo – or “TJ,” as he called her.

Law enforcement and family were his pillars – twin passions of service and devotion resulting in a happy, fulfilled life. He had what he wanted.

Then came the COVID pandemic.

Before Lynch was struck down by the virus at age 56, he had retired – in 2016, after working nearly 24 years with the Painesville Police Department and, before that, more than five years with the Cleveland Heights PD.

Soon, though, he was looking to return to service – and in March 2017 joined the Mentor Police Department as a part-time officer in the Municipal Court, a position he held until his death on Oct. 3, 2021.

“He wanted to stay occupied doing something meaningful,” said Teri-Jo, his wife of 33 years. “And he joked that the extra money would allow him to buy better whiskey and cigars.”

His wife and three daughters came first for Lynch, to the point that he made sure the family always had dinner together. And he went to great lengths to keep police work separate from home life.

“He hated it when the (police) wives were with each other because we were able to piece stories together,” Teri-Jo recalled.

A volunteer at heart, Lynch coached his daughters in tournament softball, and over the years friends looked forward to following the girls’ accomplishments through the videos he made. Before that, both he and Teri-Jo helped coach and organize T-ball teams through the Painesville Recreation Department.

As a motorcycle lover, he found a welcome outlet and a connection with military colleagues through the American Legion Riders, Post 336. As a member of the board, he helped organize an annual Poker Run to raise money for Lake County Clothe-A-Child, a northeastern Ohio charity that provides winter clothes for thousands of children.

“He was very much into giving of himself for others,” his wife said.

The Lynches were fond of traveling – to Florida and Myrtle Beach when the girls were young, to the Bahamas to renew their wedding vows for their 10^th anniversary, and to bucket-list destinations such as Ireland and Thailand when the girls were grown and out of the house. When the pandemic hit, they put a dream trip to Italy and Greece on hold, never anticipating what was to come.

Lynch joined the Army straight out of high school, eventually acquiring a NATO top-secret security clearance to serve as a military police officer at nuclear missile bases in West Germany.

In April 1987, not long after leaving the military and shortly after meeting his future wife, he was hired as a patrol officer in Cleveland Heights, moving to the Painesville department in 1992. In Painesville, he joined the supervisory staff as a sergeant in 1998 and the administrative staff as a lieutenant in 2006. He served as a shift commander and, when needed, filled in as chief.

Throughout his career in Painesville, Lynch was committed to defensive tactics training and was ultimately given command of the department's defensive tactics instructor group.

“Gerry was selfless in his work, too,” Teri-Jo said. “He always made sure he wasn’t the center of attention.”

And he was brave.

“There were a couple of occasions, when he was in Painesville, that the Lake County Blue Coats organization wanted to honor him for courageous action,” she said. “One of those times was when he had rescued some people and pets from a house fire. He said he was just doing his job, so he declined the honor but asked the Blue Coats to recognize officers who were lower in rank than he was.”

In addition to Teri-Jo, Lynch is survived by his daughters, Courtney Anne Lynch, Kayla Irene Lynch and Shannon Mary Lynch; a brother, Robert (Patricia Ann) Lynch; and a sister, Patricia Lynch; as well as several nieces and nephews.

Deputy Billy J. Ihrig
Franklin County Sheriff's Office
End of watch: Oct. 28, 2021

Before he entered law enforcement, Billy Ihrig served in the Marines. Those 13 years formed the bedrock of his life (Semper Fidelis), forever shaping his values, sense of loyalty and commitment to duty.

From the time he joined the Franklin County Sheriff’s Office in March 2004, he exuded these same character traits – no less during the COVID-19 pandemic than on any other day.

Deputy Ihrig died in the hospital of complications of COVID on Oct. 28, 2021. He is believed to have contracted the virus about a month earlier while restraining a suspect he had arrested. Ihrig was 52.

“He was a good example of a guy who wanted to serve his community and his nation,” Franklin County Sheriff Dallas Baldwin said shortly after Ihrig’s death. “And he did it. He did it in the face of danger, multiple different dangers This was tragic because COVID is an enemy you can’t see, but he was still out there doing his job – serving others.”

Ihrig started his 17-year career with the sheriff’s office in corrections, moved to the detective bureau and spent the last several years working in patrol.

The groundwork for his success there was laid from 1987 to 2000, when he served as a scout observer and, later, a drill sergeant in the Marine Corps. He left the Marines so he could spend more time with his family, which has grown to six children (now ages 33 to 13).

“Billy was a really good role model for the kids,” said his mother, Sue Wilson. “He raised them well. And that shows up even in small things, like when the boys hold open a door for somebody.”

Even as a little kid, “despite his orneriness,” Ihrig was responsible, offering to do chores to help around the house, said Sue, a single mother at the time.

Her husband, Steve Wilson, remembers Ihrig as upbeat, funny, self-confident and very disciplined – “a true go-getter.”

“He had a definite leadership quality about him,” he said. “He was always cool, never panicked, and I think his military training had a lot to do with that. If he decided to do something, he did it.”

Ihrig directed that same focus toward people in need, his mother said. When he learned of a family that was living out of motel after their home had burned down, for example, he organized donations to get them back on their feet.

“He was a stand-up guy,” she said. “He was there for a lot of people, always willing to help.”

Similar sentiments can be found in online tributes from colleagues and friends from Ihrig’s military days.

“I will miss my fellow Marine brother,” one wrote after hearing of his death. “I served with Sgt. Ihrig in Twentynine Palms, Ca. What a stud Marine. I always looked up to him because he was squared away and knew his job as well as anyone. He motivated me to be better.”

Another wrote: “As a drill instructor, Billy was tasked with shaping the hearts, minds and bodies of young Marines, inspiring them to serve their country with honor and distinction. Billy was the best of the best. He was a leader, friend, an example to all.”

His love and commitment to the military never wavered, even after leaving active service. He was a past commander of the American Legion William R. Schnug Memorial Post 614 and the Veterans of Foreign Wars Post 4931, both in Hilliard, where he lived. He also was active in the Fraternal Order of Police Capital City Lodge #9.

In addition to his mother and stepfather, Deputy Ihrig is survived by his partner of nine years, Nina Motter – “She’s like a daughter to me,” Sue Wilson said – and six children: Amanda (Nick) Marquart, Josh Ihrig, Brandon Ihrig, John Parker, Kali Ihrig and Seth Benyo; two grandchildren, Rachel and Cameron Marquart; and a brother, Aaron.

Officer Anthony E. Cloyd
University of Dayton Department of Public Safety
End of watch: Dec. 9, 2021

The University of Dayton was a great fit for Officer Cloyd. He loved working around campus, and the students, staff and faculty who got to know him loved his reassuring presence.

Cloyd served 16 years with UD police, but, like many other first responders, he contracted COVID-19 while carrying out his duties. He died Dec. 9, 2021, at age 59, the first UD officer to die in the line of duty.

“Tony was uniquely kind, he was dependable, and he was a source of wisdom for the younger officers he worked with,” said Officer Dan Little, who looked up to his partner as a father figure. “He was patient, fair and reasonable with people, regardless of who they were. He helped anyone who was in a pinch without hesitation. And he made me laugh – the hardest I’ve ever laughed. There were times I thought I had injured my abdomen.”

Cloyd became a peace officer later in life. At 43, after a career in the trucking industry, he went to the police academy, landing his first and only job in law enforcement in May 2005.  As a patrol officer, he enjoyed interacting with students and university-area residents. He was a favorite of the Flyers basketball team and close with UD President Eric Spina and Father Kip Stander, the campus minister.

“Tony was deeply committed to the University of Dayton and its people, always going out of his way to share a kind act or friendly word,” Spina said.

Sgt. Brad Swank said Cloyd looked tough and, when needed, was tough: “But this hardened, tatted-up, bad-ass guy had an emotional side that he didn’t show the world too often. We saw it at work.”

Cloyd’s wife, Deborah, said her husband’s low-profile acts of kindness made a difference. She recalled how one winter he gave a coat, gloves and a scarf to a gas station cashier whom he’d seen walking to work every day with a sweatshirt as her only outerwear.

Cloyd also once drove a young man across town to a foodbank because the foodbank in the area was closed for the day – then drove the man to his job so he wouldn’t be late.

And after a UD engineering student tragically took his own life, Cloyd met the young man’s parents when they arrived from Chicago, escorting them to the morgue and to various offices on campus.

“For at least five years after that,” Deborah said, “they sent Tony a card every year to thank him for the thoughtfulness and compassion he showed them through such a hard time.”

Her husband was no angel and spoke his mind freely, his wife said, but he always put others first. He was devoted to caring for his mother, who survived the firebombing of Nagoya, Japan, during World War II, and who in 2021 nearly died after being struck by a police cruiser that was responding to a fender-bender in which she was involved.

Likewise, Cloyd took time every day to “talk to” his deceased father, a Korean War veteran who, because of his military service, didn’t see his son for the first three years of the boy’s life. And when Cloyd’s oldest son was serving three tours as an Army Ranger in Afghanistan, Cloyd would pray for him at the same time every day, a time that the officer believed coincided with his son’s night patrols.

Cloyd was born in Hamilton in 1962. He enjoyed fishing and traveling and took a special interest in guns, knives and bourbon. He loved working out – “Made of concrete,” Little said – and was fond of motorcycles. Earlier in his life, he rode regularly with the Patriot Guard to funerals of U.S. military members as a way of honoring them.

Officer Cloyd and his wife were married 22 years. He also is survived by three sons, Corey-Levi (Casey) Cloyd, Duncan Cloyd, and Chris Lechleiter; two grandchildren, Ryli Lechleiter and Cyrus Kai Cloyd; his mother, Kimiko Cloyd; his siblings, Beth Stapleton and Terry Cloyd; and a niece, nephew and two great nephews.

Cpl. Matthew D. Mitchell
South Vienna Police Department
End of watch: Dec. 29, 2021

South Vienna Mayor Toni Keller remembers Cpl. Mitchell as the perfect fit for their village, about 10 miles east of Springfield. And she’s certain the 400 or so residents remember it that way, too.

“Whatever you needed, he was there,” Keller said. “He wanted to make sure he did the right things the right way. And in a small village, you don’t always get that. How you police here is different than in a big city. It’s community policing.”

In early December 2021, during the course of his job, Mitchell contracted COVID-19. He died on Dec. 29 at age 52.

Jake Rosales, a friend and fellow officer, said he found out Mitchell was hospitalized when he texted to ask why they hadn’t been in touch recently. Two days later, he was shocked to learn that his buddy had died.

“I’m not ashamed to say I was balling for days after that,” Rosales said. “He was the last person you’d think would succumb to COVID – he was always exercising and watching what he put in his body.”

Mitchell’s fiancee, Brooke Tigyer, said her partner was devoted to her and their two young children, both under 10. “He loved playing outside with the kids,” she said. “He was a homebody. He loved being with his family.”

Mitchell served three years with the South Vienna Police Department and, before that, five years with the South Charleston PD. Before deciding to go into law enforcement and attending Clark State Police Academy, he worked with a private investigations company. His first job out of the academy was with the Port William Police Department, in Clinton County.

South Charleston Police Chief Brian Redish said Mitchell got along with everybody – both in the department and as a member of the Clark County drug task force.

“He was serious about his work but could light up a room with his sarcasm and jokes at just the right time,” he said.

Keller, who has been mayor 21 years, said she knew right away that Mitchell would do well in South Vienna.

“When we went through the process of hiring him, and then when I swore him in – you just knew what kind of person he was,” she said. “And he proved to be one of the most caring guys around. The people of the village, in fact, everyone who knew him, loved him. When you met him, you soon felt like you’d known him forever.”

Rosales and Mitchell became friends in 2015 when Rosales joined the South Charleston department. Though now a Madison County deputy sheriff, Rosales still works part-time for South Charleston.

He considered his friend a mentor and remembers him as a lover of life. “He loved his family, loved his friends, loved his job. There was nothing he wanted more than to be a police officer and a dad.”

Brooke said Mitchell was a “people person” whose policing style was to connect with the community.

The degree of personal connection that Mitchell and his colleagues provided to South Vienna residents might be gone for good now. Unable to compete with bigger police departments in wages and benefits, the village disbanded its part-time force a year ago and contracted with the Clark County Sheriff’s Office to have a deputy assigned there five days a week.

Mitchell loved working out and loved the outdoors, especially during summer when he could cook out and swim with the kids. He and Brooke so enjoyed their first cruise vacation, a 2018 tour of Central American ports, that they planned others – but had to put the trips on hold when the COVID pandemic shut down the industry.

Cpl. Mitchell and Brooke Tigyer were together for 17 years and had two children, son Christian and daughter Calianna. He also had another son, Jordan, from a previous relationship. In addition, Mitchell is survived by a brother, Tim (Jessica) Mitchell; a sister, Tamara (Jeff) Sutton; nieces and nephews Mandy, Erin, Tyler Trevor; and his brothers and sisters in uniform.

Deputy Terrance N. Bateman
Franklin County Sheriff's Office
End of watch: Jan. 15, 2022

Faith and family. They were guiding lights for Deputy Bateman, a man whose character became a guiding light of its own for those lucky enough to know him.

He was a quiet, generous man with a servant’s heart, his colleagues said. In equal measure, he encouraged both his co-workers and the inmates he supervised.

“Mr. B never missed an opportunity to say a kind word,” colleagues at the Franklin County Sheriff’s Office wrote in an online tribute soon after his death. “He was simply loved.”

At the time, Sheriff Dallas Baldwin said: “Deputy Bateman, we will honor your memory. We will follow your example. We will never forget.”

Brenda Bateman said her husband gave whenever he saw a need – or, in some instances, just as a way of blessing people.

“God assigns people different gifts,” she said, “and the gift Terrance had was that of a giver.”

The 25-year-veteran of the sheriff’s Corrections Division succumbed to COVID-19 on Jan. 15, 2022. He was 59, a year or two away from the retirement he and his wife had been talking about.

A Cleveland native, Bateman met Brenda in June 1989 while in Columbus to visit an older brother, Chuck, a deacon at a local church. As Brenda was leaving the church one Sunday, she ran into Chuck on the front steps as he was coming in. She mentioned having met Terrance and asked his brother to pass on her regards.

When Chuck encouraged her to call Terrance, she instead hinted that Terrance could call her – and thus began a long-distance telephone relationship that, in December 1990, led to marriage. For the next 31 years, the couple worked side by side to raise five daughters and two sons.

Bateman routinely showered his wife with affection and gifts. They were best friends, and after demanding workdays at the Franklin County Corrections Center (him) and Franklin County Children Services (her), they looked forward to being homebodies together, spending hours talking or just watching the old TV shows they preferred.

As a father, Bateman never missed an opportunity to impart wisdom or direction to his children. “He was dedicated to us,” Brenda said. “He took such good care of us.”

Despite his quiet disposition, Brenda said her husband was often goofy and lighthearted, even breaking into song and dance when the mood struck him. “He made me laugh all the time.”

Underpinning everything Bateman did was a rock-solid faith. Asked how he was doing, he often replied, “Still in the master’s hands.” And whether teaching his children or talking to friends, he frequently pointed out that increased blessings from God called for increased investments into God’s kingdom and the organizations that serve his people.

Bateman knew his way around the kitchen and loved to treat the family to peach cobbler, Parmesan chicken, chili and his other specialties. He was a fan of WWE wrestling, MMA fighting and Cleveland professional sports teams, especially the Browns and Cavaliers.

Ten months after Bateman’s death, four colleagues honored their beloved friend and supported his family by joining Brenda and her children in escorting the youngest Bateman child, Zion – a drummer in the Reynoldsburg High School marching band at the time – onto the football field on Senior Night. And the deputies’ support continues, a blessing for which Brenda is forever grateful.

In addition to his wife, Deputy Bateman is survived by his children, Jocelyn Joelle, Michaela Marie, Glynnis Giselle, Randi Renae, Ethan Gilchrist, Judah Nicole and Zion Christopher; brothers, Willis (Judith) Bateman Jr. and Martin Charles “Chuck” (Alasyali) Bateman; several nieces and nephews, and a host of friends and colleagues.

Patrol Officer Timothy J. Unwin
Springfield Township Police Department
End of watch: March 31, 2023

Officer Unwin had it all going for him.

He was funny and fun-loving, disarming and charming. He enjoyed his work, and he enjoyed his life. And people loved being around him.

“He made everyone smile with his antics,” said Chief Rick Bley of the Springfield Township Police Department. “He truly made everyone a better person.”

At 31, Unwin died in a car crash on March 31, 2023, while responding to a radio call for assistance from fellow officers who were being attacked by an individual resisting arrest.

“Tim had his share of hardships, but he was definitely living his best life,” said his mother, Dawn Unwin. “Service was something he was called to do. He absolutely loved his job.”

Justin Aichele, who got to know Unwin when both worked as officers in the Hamilton Police Department, said his friend had an unforgettable personality.

“Every moment with him made an impact,” Aichele told reporters shortly after Unwin’s death. “No matter the length of time you knew Tim, he left a lifelong impact. His kindness, humor and boundless energy made others around him exhibit those exact qualities. He truly made the world a better place.”

Jake Gilbert had known Unwin since the second grade, when Gilbert’s family moved in across the street.

“Tim just popped up one day and instantly became part of the family,” Gilbert said shortly after his friend’s death. “He had an infectious way of weaving into everybody's life. People just loved Tim."

At the time of the crash, Unwin had his cruiser lights and siren on as he drove north on Hamilton Avenue in North College Hill, about 10 miles north of Cincinnati. He had shifted lanes after passing through a construction zone when his cruiser jumped the median strip in the center of the roadway, hitting an oncoming car and killing the driver.

Dawn Unwin said patrol work was something her son particularly enjoyed, as it gave him one-on-one opportunities to help the people of Springfield Township.

He never lost his cool, she said, and brought to his job the same strong will and toughness that he displayed as a young child. She recalled Tim breaking an arm as a first-grader while bouncing on the bed to the song Five Little Monkeys. She was shocked at the unnatural angle of the arm when he finally got around to showing her, and the fact that he never cried.

And during his Boy Scout days, while on a whitewater rafting trip to West Virginia, he rode through the rapids alone after everyone else – Scouts and adults alike – had been tossed overboard.

Unwin worked four years as corrections officer with Hamilton County before serving as a police officer for two years in Hamilton and two years in Springfield Township.

Chief Bley, who loved having him on his Springfield Township team, admired his approach to the job.

“His personality would never let him criticize anyone or point out how anyone stumbled or was struggling with anything,” Bley said. “Instead, he’d be the first one there making everyone around him better.

“We know he put his blood, sweat and tears into everything he did. He was a great police officer because he was an amazing person. Our community was lucky that he chose to serve here.”

Dawn Unwin said she has learned a lot about Bley and the police department.

“They are a family,” she said. “I didn’t fully appreciate that until after Tim passed, and they have absolutely carried us during the past year.”

Besides his dedication to law enforcement, tight bond with his siblings, and loyalty to a wide circle of friends, Officer Unwin was known for his passion for cars and gym workouts.

He is survived by his parents, Glenn and Dawn Unwin; his brother, Gregg Unwin, and his sister, Kim (Ryan) Hicks; and two nephews, Brayden and Braxden Hicks. He is also survived by a grandmother, grandfather, and numerous aunts, uncles and cousins.

Corrections Deputy Marcus L. Zeigler
Hamilton County Sheriff's Office
End of watch: May 26, 2023

Marcus Zeigler longed to join the Hamilton County Sheriff’s Office. When the day finally came – after he graduated from the agency’s Corrections Academy and Sheriff Charmaine McGuffey swore him in as a deputy – he and his family celebrated the start of a dream come true.

“This is something I wanted to do, and I made it and I’m going to go further,” he told his aunt Deloris Palmer, who cheered him on, saying, “You can do whatever you set your mind to.”

Sheriff McGuffey would later say: “There was no mistaking his pride in that uniform. As he stood there wearing it, I knew right then, as I was talking to him and addressing him, he was a man who would do great things for me.”

Just nine months after starting work as a corrections officer for the sheriff’s office, Zeigler collapsed during a training run while pursuing the next stage of his career – the police academy at Greak Oaks in Sharonville. The 36-year-old father of five was rushed to the hospital but died two days later.

A stunned childhood friend told a local TV station at the time that Zeigler was extremely healthy, watched what he ate, and worked out twice a day.

Relatives and friends remember Zeigler as a constant source of light – a jokester with an unfailing ability to make people laugh, an infectious personality and an unforgettable smile.

Family was his top priority, and his wife, Cassaundra, was his sunshine.

“He really loved kids and, of course, I did, too,” she said. “Early on, we realized that kids were the first real passion we shared.”

Their romance – though decidedly one-sided at first – began at Cincinnati’s Mount Healthy High School when both were 10^th-graders.

“I was in the hallway with some friends, and he basically walked up to me and told me I was going to be his girlfriend,” Cassaundra said. “I just laughed it off. ‘Yeah, right,’ I said, ‘I don’t even know you.’ And then, about six months later, guess what? I was his girlfriend.”

Except for a short break after graduation – “just long enough to make him realize what he let go,” Cassaundra joked -- they were always together.

They married in 2010, and both worked at her mother’s day-care center before later deciding to open a center of their own, Zeigler Family Daycare.

In carving out his path to becoming a deputy, Zeigler became an expert in firearms. “We had a shooting range in the backyard,” Cassaundra said. “He’d be out on that range every day he could.”

He competed in shooting events nationwide and earned multiple certifications in firearms training. From 2017 to 2022, he operated his own training business, Zeigler Defense Systems. He also worked in private security for U.S. Protection Services of Cincinnati; BWH Security of Ashland, Kentucky; and Valentis Security of Pittsburgh. During that time, he and Cassaundra continued to run their day-care business.

In his free time, Zeigler enjoyed traveling with his family, especially to Tennessee; cheering on the Bengals; and spending time with relatives and friends. He was known to carry a camera – to record the memories that were so important to him.

Cassaundra said the support she received from the Hamilton County Sheriff’s Office since her husband’s death has been remarkable.

“They’re like my extended family now. I love them all so much. They’re the greatest. They’ve helped us out with everything.”

In addition to Cassaundra, Deputy Zeigler is survived by their five children, Dominique Zeigler, Aziah Miles, Marcus Ziegler, Jr., Gionnie Zeigler and Dutchess Zeigler; his brother, Sean Zeigler; and various nieces, nephews, aunts, uncles and extended family members.

Deputy Joshua I. Hamilton
Preble County Sheriff's Office
End of watch: Dec. 18, 2023

The young career of Deputy Hamilton ended a week before Christmas last year on a dark, rural road in Preble County – a tragedy that claimed two lives and left the deputy’s young daughter fatherless.

It was just before 4 a.m., and Hamilton, on road patrol, was driving north on State Route 503, about 25 miles southwest of Dayton, when a speeding car heading south passed him.

He pulled his 2018 Ford Explorer into a driveway to turn around, then gave chase. As he was trying to catch up to the speeding car, Hamilton rounded a curve between the towns of Gratis and West Alexandria and collided with a motorist coming from the opposite direction.

Hamilton, 34, and the other driver, 36, were killed. The speeding motorist got away.

Deputy Hamilton had been with the Preble County Sheriff’s Office about 18 months, since May 2022. He was assigned to the jail until June 2023, when he was promoted to road patrol. He also worked as an officer for Premier Health Network.

His daughter, Mikaelah, was 10 years old at the time of the crash and is now in the care of Hamilton’s parents, Pat and John.

Hamilton grew up on a dairy farm in western Ohio and enjoyed hunting, football and wrestling in his youth.

“He was mischievous but had a very tender heart,” his mother recalled.

For as long as she can remember, her son had his sights set on a career in law enforcement. The path he planned and ultimately followed was to join the military, use the GI Bill to attend college, then enroll in a police academy.

In 2009, Hamilton enlisted in the Navy, serving on the USS Nimitz. Four years later, the aircraft carrier was scheduled to return to the United States at a time that, coincidentally, would have allowed him to get home for the birth of his daughter. Instead, to his great disappointment, his sea duty was extended when another aircraft carrier in the fleet was forced to return to port for repairs.

“He was devoted to Mikaelah, and that’s why he was awarded custody when the divorce eventually went through,” Pat said. “He talked to her every day when he was in the Navy and wasn’t on maneuvers.

“I bought two Stars and Stripes-themed Beanie Babies – one big, one little. Mikaelah got the big one so she could cuddle with it. And Josh carried the little one in his uniform where it couldn’t be seen. When he would FaceTime with her, he’d have his Beanie Baby and she had hers. It was their little thing, a way to connect when they were apart.”

When his six-year obligation with the Navy ended in 2015, Hamilton joined the Navy Reserve, then switched to the Army National Guard in 2023. During this time, he graduated from the Greene County Career Center Basic Peace Officer Academy and three months later, in June 2021, earned a bachelor’s degree in criminal justice from American Military University.

“Deputy Hamilton was very team-oriented in his day-to-day duties and was always focused on the task at hand,” Preble County Sheriff Mike Simpson said. “Our office took a gut punch with his death. He served his country and community with honor.”

Pat Hamilton said her son’s death and funeral were made even more tragic by the timing, mere days before Christmas. Through it all, though, the sheriff’s office was there to help the family, and it has been there ever since.

“On Christmas day, the office asked if some folks could drop by,” she recalled. “Next thing you know, six cruisers pull up to the house, and deputies are bringing in all sorts of gifts for Mikaelah. One of them was a bike. I never saw my granddaughter smile so much. Everyone at that office – including secretaries and deputies’ wives – was extremely supportive. I’m overwhelmed by their kindness.”

In addition to his daughter and parents, Deputy Hamilton is survived by a sister, Rebecca (Brad) Wenning; three grandmothers, Jessie Boekel, Betty Hamilton and Viola Sandlin; and numerous aunts, uncles and cousins.

Officer Kenneth C. Jones
Akron Police Department
End of watch: Nov. 7, 2020

Officer Jones was beginning a new chapter of his life when he was struck down by a heart attack.

Just six weeks earlier, he had remarried, happily in love again after having lost his first wife to cancer in 2016.

News of his death stunned the Akron Police Department.

“It was an absolute shock to everyone because he was such a physically imposing guy,” Lt. Michael Miller said. “He was nearly 6 feet 5 and . . .  appeared to be in great physical shape. We were devastated.”

Officer Jones’ faith, which served him so constantly throughout his life, was the focus of many colleagues’ memories of him.

“If you presented any issues to Kenny, he would always pray for you,” friend and fellow Officer Calvin Barker told reporters soon after Jones’ death. “He prayed for people in the streets when they were going through stuff. He didn't have a mean bone in his body.”

Capt. Kris Beitzel, who joined the department in 1994, echoed those sentiments.

“Kenny was literally the kindest person I've ever known,” she said. “That came from his faith in God. It came from just the general goodness of who he was.”

Miller said Jones’ actions reflected his values.

“You knew Kenny was a man of faith by the way he lived his life, the way he loved his children, the way that he loved his wife,” he said. “He would often share positive words of affirmation, of encouragement and even prayer when necessary, and it was always the right balance. So it never struck anyone as overbearing or inappropriate because he had a gift for discernment and knew what someone needed in a certain moment.

“He helped other people be stronger.”

On the Friday afternoon of Nov. 6, 2020, Officer Jones responded to a domestic-assault call involving a child. A crowd of family members and bystanders had gathered and grew increasingly belligerent and confrontational with the officers on the scene.

Officer Jones transported a suspect back to the station and later told his supervisors that he had experienced pain in his chest during the incident. That evening at home, when he complained of pain in his throat, his wife drove him to Summa Akron City Hospital, where his condition worsened. He passed away on Saturday.

He was 55 and had served with the Akron Police Department for 26 years, the vast majority of the time in the patrol division.

The soft-spoken Jones was a “gentle giant” whose calmness had a way of defusing tense situations. His colleagues said even the people he interacted with on the streets or transported to jail or mental-health facilities seemed to appreciate his empathy and respected the way he went about his job.

In all that he did, Miller said, he acted with a sense of humanity.

“He really was an angel on Earth. Maybe it sounds cliché, but the tributes that poured in after his death –  thousands of people telling the exact same story – only reinforced how blessed we felt to know and work with Kenny.”

Jones was born in Arizona but was a lifetime resident of Akron. He attended Garfield High School and the University of Akron, and later graduated from the Akron Police Academy.

Friends and family say he was a big kid at heart who was fond of Marvel comics, Star Wars movies, movie theater popcorn and amusement parks, especially Cedar Point. He was an excellent artist, loved to sing, and had an appreciation for all genres of music.

He is survived by his wife, Stacy Hairston-Jones; three teenage children from his first marriage, daughters Havilland and Eunice and son Xavier; his father; and two brothers and a sister. He was preceded in death by his first wife, Rhonda, and his mother, Barbara.

“There’s not a single person who has an ill thing to say about Kenny,” Miller said. “Simply by his example, he would encourage you to be a better man, a better human being. And that's one of the things about him that I’ll miss forever.”

Officer Edward L. Stewart
Akron Police Department
End of watch: Feb. 12, 2021

Officer Stewart was known for his devotion to his community and his ever-present kindness. Integrity, humility and passion defined both his personality and his career.

“Stew wrote the script for what a public servant should be,” said Lt. Michael Miller of the Akron Police Department. Miller said he regarded his friend as a mentor, the godfather of the department.

Others did, too.

“If there was one word that describes him, it’s ‘respect,’ ” Sgt. Brent Bauknecht told reporters shortly after Officer Stewart’s death. His colleague’s exemplary character and conduct, Bauknecht said, made a lasting positive impact on the community.

Stewart died at age 60 after a two-month battle with COVID-19.

“It really shocked us,” Miller said. “Midway through, we had heard there was some improvement – so there was a great expectation that Stew would recover. And then, before we knew it, he had taken a turn for the worse and was gone.”

Compounding the loss was the death a few months earlier, in November 2021, of Akron Officer Kenneth Jones, who suffered a heart attack at age 55. Jones and Stewart, both assigned to the patrol division, were like brothers.

Miller said that even when Officer Stewart was in the hospital intensive care unit, he was focused on getting back to work.

“He said he didn’t want to let anyone down. That struck me because, even as uncertain as his situation was, his thoughts were on serving others. He set the bar high. This department and this community lost a great man.”

Edward Stewart began his career as a civilian employee in 1993 before pursuing his passion and joining the Akron Police Department’s academy in December 1994. After graduating, he joined the patrol division and served the community as a transport wagon officer, where he remained, by choice, for his entire 27-year career with the department.

Colleagues talked about the relentless enthusiasm with which he carried out his job and lived his life. In fact, Stewart was eligible for retirement but continued working because “of his love and passion for the community,” Miller said.

Before entering law enforcement, Stewart served 14 years in the Air Force. During his tenure, he met the love of his life, Lisa, with whom he raised a family over the course of their 35-year marriage.

Miller said Officer Stewart had “a strong, commanding, yet humble presence” among his colleagues and was always one of the first to respond to assist his fellow officers, even in the most critical moments. In addition, he was continually looking for ways to improve his own performance and the efficiency of the department as a whole.

“If you saw him with his hands empty, something was wrong because he was known for studying reports and other research from around Ohio and the nation,” Miller said. “It was something new every day. It might be about safety or technology, but it always related to helping us serve the community better, helping us do our jobs better.”

On top of that, his colleagues said, Officer Stewart had a photographic memory – a gift that, among other things, enabled him to identify license plates mentioned in the reports he regularly consumed. He knew not only that a vehicle had been stolen, Miller said, but also the day and time it was taken and the location of the theft – information he could recall even weeks later.

Ultimately, though, his abundant compassion is what colleagues remember most vividly – and Officer Stewart showed it at all times, even with the men and women he took to jail, Miller said.

“He drove the wagon and saw these people in their worst moments. Yet he always offered kindness and understanding.”

In addition to his wife, Officer Stewart is survived by two sons, Jason and Leland; two grandsons, Carter and Mehki; six brothers; two sisters; his mother-in-law and extended family members.

Deputy Robert "Craig" Mills
Butler County Sheriff's Office
End of Watch: Sept. 12, 2021
Memorial Wall: Panel 23

Deputy Mills was a kindhearted, disciplined and passionate person who treated everyone with respect and fiercely loved his friends and family. Or, as a friend described him, he was a “one phone call” kind of person – someone who, when contacted, was there to help right away, no questions asked.

Mills, known to family and friends as Craig, was 57 and had been with the Butler County Sheriff’s Office for 32 years when he died on Sept. 12, 2021,  after a lengthy battle with  COVID-19. He had actually retired in June 2019, only to return several months later to the work he enjoyed at the urging of Sheriff Richard Jones.

“You couldn’t ask for a better deputy, and we needed him back,” Jones said. “His job was to find people and serve warrants, and nobody did it better. Other agencies from our county and around the state would even turn to him if they needed help. He had an unbelievable instinct and an amazing rapport with people.”
 
Those who knew him best say he was especially compassionate and generous, too. Friend and colleague David Rumpler said it wasn’t uncommon for Mills to dig into his own pocket to buy groceries for struggling families he encountered when serving warrants.
 
“He never met a stranger,” Rumpler told the Butler County Journal-News. “No matter what the cover of the book looked like, he never met a stranger.”
 
Sheriff Jones said Deputy Mills was born and raised in the Hamilton area and often knew the people he interacted with.
 
“He never forgot where he came from, all the way to the end,” Jones said. “He was just one of those people who always showed up when he knew someone needed something. He was always there, no matter how tough it was, no matter what other things he had to do. To me, that’s his biggest legacy.”
 
Always a star athlete, Mills was drafted by the Detroit Tigers in 1982 and played Triple-A baseball through 1987. He would later be inducted into the Hamilton High School Athletic Hall of Fame and the Butler County Softball Hall of Fame.
 
Throughout his life, he mentored athletes in the Hamilton area, and the City Council has since commemorated his tireless contributions by voting to name the street leading to the North End Baseball/Softball Complex in his honor. It’s no coincidence, Jones said, that Craig Mills Way happens to connect with a street named for another Hamilton baseball legend: Joe Nuxhall, a former Cincinnati Reds pitcher and announcer.
 
“Hamilton High contends for the state baseball championship almost every year, it seems,” Jones said. “We’re always right up at the top. It was Craig who helped mentor a lot of these young men and their coaches. He gave back till his last breath.”
 
The street naming was backed by Mayor Pat Moeller, who worked with Deputy Mills in the prosecutor’s office. The proponents of the measure said it wasn’t only Mills’ involvement in law enforcement and sports that qualified him for the honor, but also his heart and willingness to help others in need.
 
When he wasn’t around a baseball field, Deputy Mills was typically pursuing his other favorite outdoor pastime – fishing. And he was good at, with trophies from various professional bass tournaments to prove his prowess. It was a passion he especially enjoyed sharing with the city’s disadvantaged kids through Fish With a Cop, a tournament he helped organize.
 
“A lot of these kids didn’t have a dad,” Jones said. “They had never held a fishing pole or baited a hook. But you should have seen them laughing and giggling over the fish they brought in, even the little bitty fish that were barely bigger than the bait. They were so happy.”
 
Deputy Mills’ funeral honored his love of fishing: His bass boat was towed right behind the hearse in the procession to the cemetery. “If he had his way,” Jones said, “he probably would have been in the boat.”
 
There was no doubt, though, about the greatest source of passion in Deputy Mills’s life: his children, Megan and Alex. He loved spending time with them and rarely missed one of their sporting events or school events, Jones said.
 
In addition to his kids, Mills is survived by his wife of nearly 27 years, Anne Vaaler Mills, and his sister, Rayetta Fields, as well as in-laws, nieces and nephews, and numerous extended family members.
 
“What a great and wonderful person,” Jones said. “We miss him every day.”

Patrolman Sean E. VanDenberg
Lawrence Twp. Police Department 
End of watch: Dec. 25, 2021
Memorial Wall: Panel 24

Patrolman Sean VanDenberg came to law enforcement at a much older age than most cops do.
 
After a career as a mechanic, welder and fabricator, he decided to chase his dream of becoming a police officer, entering the Stark State College Law Enforcement Academy at age 44 in 2012. A year later, he joined the Lawrence Township Police Department in Stark County.
 
His colleagues at the academy and the police department valued the wisdom he brought to the job and the manner with which he dispensed it. He was the “Dad” of the department, Police Chief David Brown said.
 
What people don’t know, the patrolman’s wife of 21 years said, is that “he was scared to death to go to the academy” at his age. Despite that, Jeanann VanDenberg said, he graduated second in his class and often wondered why he hadn’t gone into law enforcement much sooner.
 
“‘It was God’s plan,’ I told him. ‘He wanted you to be older and more mature.’”
 
Patrolman VanDenberg spent six years on the Canton-area SWAT team, was a certified sniper and firearms instructor, and was always eager to help his colleagues.
 
“I think his favorite role was field training officer,” Chief Brown said. “He really enjoyed taking our new people under his wing. He had a real knack for training and loved learning new tactics and procedures. Sean used every day as a teaching moment.”
 
Patrolman VanDenberg died of COVID-19, which he contracted on Dec. 3, 2021, after arresting a man and transporting him to jail. The suspect had complained of being sick and showed symptoms of COVID. Despite the precautions he took, he fell ill the next day and was taken to the hospital, where he later tested positive for the virus. Organ failure eventually ensued and, according to Brown, “everything that could have gone wrong went wrong.”

He died on Christmas at age 53, in his eighth year with the Lawrence Township Police Department.
 
Jeanann VanDenberg remembers her husband as “an all-around good person” who cared about people and his community. “He opened his heart to everybody,” she said.
 
In his spare time, Patrolman VanDenberg enjoyed a wide range of athletic pursuits, including working out, cycling, running and scuba diving. He had completed his first ultra-marathon just six months before his death.
 
That he died on Christmas and had been so fit and healthy before contracting COVID seems cruelly ironic – something she and her children have thought about frequently, Jeanann VanDenberg said.
 
But she reconciles the irony this way: “With Sean being such a believer, a man of such deep faith, I don't think he would have died on any other day.”
 
She feared, in fact, that he might die on Christmas Eve, a concern that inspired her to prayer: ‘God,’ I said, ‘I’m going to have a selfish moment. Please do not take him on my mom's birthday. It will devastate her.’”
 
Her mother, she said, loved Sean dearly. When her husband finally did pass, she looked at her watch: It was 12:02,  two minutes into Christmas morning.
 
Not long after the funeral, Jeanann VanDenberg recalled, a young man whom her husband had stopped for speeding reached out to her through Facebook.
 
“He said he’d been a jerk to Sean, swearing at him and generally giving him a hard time. Still, the young man said, Sean talked to him for 20 minutes – ‘like I was a real person.’” The young man concluded his condolence by saying, “I really respect and look up to your husband and just wanted to let you know that.”
 
The anecdote reinforces Patrolman VanDenberg’s character and his sense of fairness.
 
“He gave people the benefit of the doubt and did everything he could to put them in a better place,” Chief Brown said. “It didn’t matter whether a person was the victim of a crime or the suspect; he always helped them be better at that moment.”
 
The patrolman, known for his sunny disposition, made it a practice of wishing the department’s dispatchers a cheery “good morning” when calling in for service.
 
“They looked forward to it every morning,” Chief Brown said – so much so that department played a recording of the patrolman’s daily greeting at his funeral.
 
“Everybody knew Sean and everybody loved him,” said Brown, noting that his death has been “a difficult time for a lot of people in this community.”
 
In addition to his wife, Patrolman VanDenberg is survived by four grown children – Erin, Ryan, Maxwell and John – three grandchildren, his mother, three siblings, and many extended family members. VanDenberg’s father passed away six months after his son died.
 

Agent John D. Stayrook
Medina County Drug Task Force 
End of watch: Feb. 6, 2022
Memorial Wall: Panel 25

John Stayrook took on the inherent dangers of drug-task-force work for a simple reason: He wanted to protect and improve the communities he served in northeastern Ohio.
 
“John was a true hero and dedicated his life to serving others and making the state of Ohio a safer place for all of us,” said his boss, Darren Stout, the director of the Medina County Drug Task Force, an independent agency that serves 14 law enforcement departments in the county. “John was truly passionate about what he did for the community, and his death leaves a great void. It was an honor to serve alongside him, and his memory will live on forever with the task force.”
 
Agent Stayrook died after contracting COVID-19 while assisting Brunswick police during a drug-related traffic stop in January 2022. He spent a couple of days at home but, when breathing became difficult, was rushed to the hospital, where he eventually was moved to the intensive care unit and put on a respirator.
 
Through all of this, Agent Stayrook stayed upbeat and positive. Instead of focusing on his own well-being, Stout said, “he looked at it as more of an inconvenience for his family and the agency.”
 
His friend and colleague fought COVID for nearly a month before passing away. He was 60.
 
Agent Stayrook found his way to law enforcement later in life, after a career in construction that had taken him all over the country.
 
“He got bit by the bug,” Stout said. “His career path, I would venture to say, was different than most every other law enforcement officer’s in the state of Ohio in that he put himself through the academy and directly got into the drug enforcement specialization. This was his passion.”
 
After graduating from the Medina County Law Enforcement Academy, he was hired in 2003 by the Medway Drug Enforcement Agency in Wayne County, where he worked until 2007 before joining the Medina County Drug Task Force.
 
Medina County Sheriff Terry Grice said Agent Stayrook dedicated himself to the task force’s mission.
 
“His passion to do the right thing was very evident,” Grice said. “He was a remarkable agent and a tremendous person, and will be missed by all those who had the privilege to know him.”
 
Jason Waddell, director of the Medway DEA, said Agent Stayrook’s work ethic was second to none, noting that he was always willing to teach, learn and help out.
 
“He was just great to work with,” Waddell said.
 
Stout said Agent Stayrook was analytical and matter-of-fact but also had a unique talent for getting people “to open up to him more than anybody I've ever seen in my career. He was very empathetic and caring.”
 
Julie Ruic, an administrative assistant with the Medina County Drug Task Force, said Agent Stayrook’s smile was like a barometer indicating good times ahead: “Whenever John would get that grin, you knew something funny was about to happen or be said.”
 
But he wasn’t funny just to be funny; he lived his life to bring light into the world around him.
 
“John never knew a stranger,” Stout said. “He had the gift of gab and he knew it. He knew how to navigate any problem with just his wit and humor.
 
“He could get the whole room just rolling with laughter at any given point, even if it was a somber situation. . . .  That's what drew so many people to him and helped him in in his daily life as a drug enforcement agent, as a husband, father and grandfather. Everywhere John went, he was unconditionally loved.”
 
Agent Stayrook is survived by his wife, Pamela; his children, Adam and Jacqueline; his siblings, Blain and Margaret; and his two grandchildren, Breckon and Rowen.
 
A talented woodworker, he liked to unwind in his garage workshop by crafting animals, rocking horses and one-of-a-kind items, especially for his grandkids. He also liked camping with family and friends, and helping out with the Shop With A Cop program at Christmastime.
 
Agent Stayrook’s greatest sense of accomplishment, he would tell people, came from being a father and grandfather. Friends and family say he combined a deep love of life with a sincere appreciation of its greatest joy: the simplicity of being with loved ones.

Officer Dominic M. Francis
Bluffton Police Department  
End of watch: March 31, 2022
Memorial Wall: Panel 26

Dominic “Dom” Francis was part of the fabric of his northwestern Ohio community, someone who touched many lives in different ways.
 
A full-time member of the Bluffton Police Department, Officer Francis also served his neighbors as a volunteer firefighter in the Southwestern Hancock Joint Fire Department. In addition, he worked as a strength-and-conditioning coach, football coach, substitute teacher and bus driver at Cory-Rawson High School, his alma mater.
 
He also had a special fondness for helping the school’s softball coach – Ricki Francis, his wife since 2010.
 
“His involvement in the community went a lot further than just his dedication to serve and protect,” Bluffton Police Chief Ryan Burkholder said. “He was always willing to be a teacher and mentor, both inside the department and outside the department, and that speaks volumes about his character and personality.”
 
A stolen car being pursued by Ohio State troopers struck and killed Officer Francis as he was deploying tire-puncturing stop strips on southbound I-75 in Hancock County. At times, the car reached speeds exceeding 130 mph.
 
“This community lost a hero,” Burkholder said. “He was an outstanding police officer with a very big heart.”
 
Amanda Miller, a dispatcher in the Hancock County Sheriff's Office, described Francis, a close friend and colleague, as a peacemaker. They had both dreamed of pursuing careers in police work, she said, since they met at age 16 as members of the sheriff office’s Explorers post.
 
“Service was as natural to him as breathing,” Miller said.
 
The superintendent of Cory-Rawson Local Schools, Jay Clark, told news media that the impact of Francis’ death is profound: “Our community is a small place. They all knew who Dominic was.”
 
Officer Francis,  42 when he died, had worked in law enforcement for 19 years. Before joining the Bluffton Police Department, where he served 11 years, he worked for the Findlay Police Department and the Hancock County Sheriff’s Office.
 
He was named Officer of the Year twice and had received the Chief’s Leadership Award and the Bluffton Police Department’s Life-Saving Award. He also was honored by Mothers Against Drunk Drivers as Top Cop and earned the Ohio EMS Star of Life multiple times.
 
Ohio Attorney General Dave Yost met Officer Francis in 2019 when he received the Top Cop Award. “His last act was heroic, but that was not what made him a hero,” said Yost, who spoke at the funeral. “He was already a hero.”
 
Burkholder, who met Francis when they attended high school together, said compassion was a cornerstone of his friend’s life.
 
“He always tried to work with the people he met on the job so they didn’t fall into a cycle of wrong behavior,” the chief said. “He gave them the opportunity to better themselves because he saw their potential. And he lived by what he said.”
 
Burkholder recounted an exchange he had with a stranger shortly after Francis’ funeral. The man approached him, he said, and explained that he was probably on his “third strike” when Officer Francis spent some time with him and made it clear that he had to make choice – either stay on the dead-end track he was on or steer a new course.
 
“The gentleman is doing very well now,” Burkholder said. “That interaction happened just several months before Dom’s passing, and it was very moving to hear how his concern had changed the guy’s life.”
 
In March 2023, Emin Johnson, the 21-year-old man who was driving the stolen car that struck Francis, pleaded guilty to six charges and was sentenced to 21 to 26½ years in prison. Two passengers in the car had previously pleaded guilty.
 
Ricki Francis spoke at Johnson’s sentencing, saying: “Dom was my best friend, my soulmate, my partner in everything, and the best person I’ve ever met in my life. … We were a team like no other. And you took that from me.”
 
She then forgave Johnson.
 
“Dom was always about second chances,” she said. “Forgiveness was important to him, and to me. I forgive you, and Dom would forgive you.”
 
In addition to his wife, Officer Francis is survived by his son, Blake Francis; daughter, Taylor Born; parents, Robert and Vicky Francis; and sister, Chase Eikenbary. Family and friends meant everything to him, and he especially enjoyed boating with them at Indian Lake.
 
A four-mile stretch of I-75 at Bluffton has been renamed the Officer Dominic Francis Memorial Highway to commemorate his bravery.

Deputy Matthew E. Yates
Clark County Sheriff's Office
End of Watch: July 24, 2022
Memorial Wall: Panel 27

Matthew Yates followed in his father’s footsteps, choosing a career in law enforcement because he believed a good peace officer could make a difference. He lived by that philosophy during his 15 years with the Clark County Sheriff’s Office, often sharing it with kids who might aspire to wear the badge someday. 
 
Tragically, Deputy Yates’ life was cut short on July 24, 2022, when he and other deputies responded to a call about a woman attempting to get into a residence at the Harmony Estates Mobile Home Park, east of Springfield, where shots had been fired.
 
The woman, it turned out, had gone to the mobile home to check on her son out of concern for his mental health – and was shot and killed by him.
 
As deputies entered the mobile home, they were met with gunfire. Deputy Yates, a member of the special operations team, was hit and went down. Other tactical officers were called to the scene to rescue him but were kept at bay by the shooter inside the mobile home. After several hours, members of the tactical team stormed in and retrieved Yates. In the process, the mobile home caught fire and was destroyed; the bodies of the mother and son were later recovered in the remains.
 
Deputy Yates was transported to Miami Valley Hospital in Dayton, where he was pronounced dead. He was 41.
 
At his funeral, Clark County Sheriff Deborah Burchett called him “a warrior” who “devoted his life to making his community better.”
 
Major Mike Young said Deputy Yates “simply embodied goodness. If we gave out medals for every person that Matt made feel special, valued, loved or protected, there wouldn’t have been enough space on his shirt.”
 
Deputy John Loney said his friend left a lasting impression on the community: “There is not a day that goes by that you don’t hear something about Matt, or somebody asks about him.” Even inmates in the county jail were moved by his death, Loney said. “Some of them went so far as to write ‘RIP, Deputy Yates’ on the windows. That says it all about Matt right there.”
 
Another close friend, Deputy Fitzroy Lawrence, said Deputy Yates enjoyed working with young kids and teens. He was involved in a group called Peace Keepers and had been invited to speak at a local school that was dealing with race issues.
 
Humor was one way he put people at ease, his colleagues said. And sometimes the laughs were unintentional.  
 
Lawrence recalled working a third shift at the jail with his friend several years back. After doing their rounds, they ducked into the weight room, where Yates began doing squats.
 
“The next thing I heard was a tear, like paper ripping,” Lawrence said. “I looked over, and he dropped the weight real quick and put his hand behind his backside and said, ‘I just ripped my pants.’ Then he took off out of there. I never saw him move so quick. By the time the next checks rolled around, he had stapled up his pants so it looked like something out of a Frankenstein movie. I had tears in my eyes.”
 
Yates is survived by his wife, Tracy; a daughter, A’kaylehana, known as AK; and two sons, Anthony Reed and Andrew Reed. Matt and Tracy both graduated from Clark State College’s Peace Officer Academy. Tracy left law enforcement, but Matt eventually landed at the Clark County Sheriff’s Office, where his father, Eugene, had served for many years.
 
Loney, whose father also served in the sheriff’s office, knew Matt when they were kids and remembers how often they talked about following their fathers into law enforcement: “Matt was destined to wear the badge.”
 
Even more than his commitment to law enforcement, however, Deputy Yates will be remembered for his devotion to his family, Loney said.
 
“He was definitely that type of guy. They always had all of his love and support. And at the same time, he wanted them to branch out, do lots of things on their own – to spread their wings, so to speak.”
 
His sons spoke at the funeral service, remembering their stepdad as “the only father they ever had,” a loving man who, by marrying their mother, “made their family whole.”
 
In addition to his wife, children and father, Yates leaves behind his mother, Lisa; two sisters; four brothers; and numerous extended family members and friends.
 
Clark State College has established a scholarship fund in his honor that will be supported by an annual basketball tournament organized by his friends at the sheriff’s office.

Deputy Daniel J. Kin
Wyandot County Sheriff’s Office 
End of Watch: Dec. 15, 2022
Memorial Wall: Panel 28

Daniel Kin had been with the Wyandot County Sheriff’s Office for only a little more than a year when he died, but his personality was already a hallmark of the northwestern Ohio agency.

He was a welcome addition to the force, his colleagues said – fun, hard-working and down-to-earth. He loved the job, and it showed in his infectious smile.

“He was just a great fit for our office, and he won everybody's heart right off the bat,” Sheriff Todd Frey said. “I always describe Dan as a ray of sunshine. He had a passion for the job and a positive outlook on life. He could walk into any room and just brighten up everybody’s day.”
 
Deputy Kin was transporting a prisoner from southern Ohio to the county courthouse in Wyandot when he was fatally injured in a crash in Pickaway County. The accident occurred just west of Circleville, at State Routes 56 and 104. The department van that he was driving was headed north when it was struck on the driver’s door by a pickup truck going east on S.R. 56.
 
Deputy Kin was flown to Grant Medical Center in Columbus, where he died of his injuries at age 34. The prisoner suffered non-life-threatening injuries, and the pickup driver and a 4-year-old girl who was with him were treated at Columbus hospitals.
 
“We’re a small agency in a small community,” Frey said. “The people who work here see each other on a regular basis, so we’re close-knit – we’re family. When Dan passed away, we lost a dear family member.”
 
Upon joining the Wyandot County Sheriff’s Office in October 2021, Deputy Kin was assigned to the transport division. “He grew up in Wyandot County and graduated from Mohawk High School,” Frey said. “This was pretty much his dream job to be in his home county.”
 
Kin started in law enforcement with the Carey Police Department, then moved to the Seneca County Sheriff’s Office, where he was hired in 2010 and in 2020 was voted Deputy of the Year by his co-workers.
 
Nathan Frasure met Kin in 2008 while both attended the police academy at Terra State Community College in Fremont; they later worked together at the Seneca County Sheriff’s Office.
 
"I think you run out of words to describe somebody that good who has moved on at such an early age in life,” Frasure told WBNS-TV in Columbus. “I was very fortunate to cross paths with somebody like that in my life.”  
 
Sheriff Frey said Deputy Kin always sought bigger challenges and, about a week before his death, had asked permission to work on a wanted-person case.
 
“He worked on the case like it was the biggest thing in the world, and he ended up locating the guy in Oklahoma,” the sheriff said. “So the day before his accident, he asks my detective, ‘If I find this guy, do you think the sheriff will let me go out and get him?’ And I told the detective that Dan would absolutely be the one to send out there. But the day after that, he passed away.
 
“Oklahoma authorities found the guy and arrested him, and we brought him back a few days later. Dan’s persistence obviously paid off. It was a great outcome, thanks to his hard work.”
 
The son of a farmer, Deputy Kin enjoyed a lifelong connection to the land. In high school, he was a member of the Future Farmers of America and served on the Wyandot County Junior Fair Board. As an adult, when he wasn’t in uniform, he was growing grain and raising livestock with his father, Franklin. He especially loved being outdoors, whether working with cattle, cutting firewood, collecting mushrooms or just enjoying wildlife.
 
Deputy Kin and his wife of six years, Erin, and their two young boys, Jaxon and Arlo, were members of Our Lady of Consolation Catholic Church in Carey.
 
“He was a very devoted father, husband, son, brother and co-worker,” Frey said. “He was very passionate about his family.”
 
In addition to his wife, children and father, Deputy Kin is survived by six sisters – Jennifer Eckstein, Cassandra Sampsell, Stephanie Kitzler, Elizabeth Kin, Hillarie Kin and Roxie Kin – his father-in-law and brother-in-law, and a large extended family. His mother, Susan, preceded him in death.

Brandon Stalker
Toledo Police Department
End of watch: Jan. 18, 2021

Police Officer Brandon Stalker intended to spend his life helping the people of Toledo. However, less than three years into his dream job with the city’s police department, the 24-year-old was fatally shot during a standoff.

The shooter, who had earlier set a fire at the door of Toledo’s Rosary Cathedral, ran into a home when the department’s Gang Task Force members recognized him. Police, including Officer Stalker, set up a perimeter.

The SWAT team couldn’t persuade the man to give himself up, so officers fired a chemical irritant inside the house. He came out shooting, and one bullet struck Officer Stalker in the head. He died at a local hospital.

Officers returning fire hit the shooter multiple times and killed him.

Officer Stalker had a new son and an older daughter, and he was engaged to be married. He also was survived by his parents, grandparents, five siblings and many more family members and good friends.

The Toledo native enjoyed roller skating, bowling and riding his motorcycle. He played baseball in several leagues while at Whitmer High School and later became a coach there.

“A fantastic officer and a proud new dad, his loss will be felt forever,” said Toledo Mayor Wade Kapszukiewicz, who noted Officer Stalker was Toledo’s second officer killed on duty in the past year.

Police Officer Anthony Dia and Officer Stalker had graduated from the academy in the same recruit class.

Deputy Donald R. Gilreath III
Hamilton County Sheriff's Office
End of watch: Feb. 12, 2021

Like law enforcement officers everywhere, Deputy Gilreath didn’t have the luxury of retreating to the safety of his home when COVID-19 turned the world upside-down in 2020. As much of society quarantined, he continued his duties as a jail service deputy at the Hamilton County Justice Center, where he oversaw the control room and came into contact with everyone who entered and left the building.

Whether it was jail officials, lawyers or visitors coming to see prisoners, Deputy Gilreath always greeted them with a kind word and a laugh. During his 15-year career, he went out of his way to make people feel good. But those who got to know him soon learned that his love of family truly defined who he was.

Gilreath, 36, contracted COVID-19 while at work and later died from complications of the virus. He is survived by his wife, a son, two daughters, parents, sisters, nieces and nephews, and extended family.

Jason Lagore
Ohio Department of Natural Resources
End of watch: Feb. 23, 2021

Officer Lagore had 15 years of rescues, searches and park security under his belt when the call came in on the evening of Feb. 23, 2021, that a 16-year-old girl had disappeared beneath the ice on a Highland County lake.

“He assisted on countless, countless search-and-rescues, bringing closure to families and also finding people and being able to help them,” a friend, Shaun Lentini, told WLWT-TV (Channel 5) of Cincinnati.

Officer Lagore, a married father of two, responded to the lake in Rocky Fork State Park but suffered an apparent heart attack on a dock near where the teen and her 13-year-old brother had gone into the water.

The dedicated officer, 36, fell into the lake and was pulled out by fellow first responders. He was pronounced dead at a hospital in Hillsboro.

The teenage girl was found a few hours later. She had managed to get her brother out of the water before getting stuck under the ice and drowning. The boy was hospitalized with hypothermia but survived.

The loss of Officer Lagore was felt across the state, as he was respected by many for his work training K-9s, notably for the water recovery of missing people. He started ODNR’s K-9 program and led the K-9 academy.

“I talked with a lot of people who had worked with him and heard nothing but praise,” Attorney General Dave Yost said.

Officer Lagore had been stationed at Caesar Creek State Park in Warren County since 2005. When he wasn’t proudly serving, ODNR reported, he enjoyed deer and turkey hunting, history and vacations with his family.

Officer Lagore is survived by his wife, Michelle; two young sons; and his K-9 partner, Sarge.

 

Scott Dawley
Nelsonville Police Department
End of watch: Aug. 3, 2021

Just before 2:30 p.m. on Aug. 3, a call came in warning of shots fired on the east side of Nelsonville, a town of about 6,000 residents in Southeast Ohio.

Officer Dawley was responding, with lights and sirens activated, when his SUV struck a box truck head-on at the intersection of Canal Street and Myers Street/Hocking Street, in front of the Rocky Boots outlet store.

EMS workers started CPR on the 43-year-old officer at the scene, but he did not survive the trip to OhioHealth O’Bleness Hospital in nearby Athens.

The other driver was flown by helicopter to a Columbus hospital. A couple in a third car that was struck were not injured.

As the third-most-senior officer at the Nelsonville Police Department, Officer Dawley was well known and respected as a selfless officer with a good sense of humor. He had served for seven years.

The Carbon Hill resident is survived by his wife, Marissa; children Taylor, Bryanna, Ashton, Paige, Ava, Evan and Keira; his father, Russ Dawley; and many more loved ones and friends.

“This is a tragic event and I can’t even begin to express how sorry I am for Scott Dawley and his family,” Nelsonville Police Chief Scott Fitch said.

The fatal crash occurred just a week after another Nelsonville police officer was shot on the job. He will survive, but the pair of critical incidents shook the 10-man department.

Officer Shane H. Bartek
Cleveland Division of Police
End of watch: Dec. 31, 2021

Always true to his family’s principles, Officer Bartek was constantly extending himself during his two-year career. He spent time reading at a child care center. He loved the Shop with a Cop program at Christmastime. And his partners fondly remember how he helped a drug-addled Navy vet who was threatening suicide.

Officer Bartek, 25, was shot and killed on New Year’s Eve at a West Side apartment complex when he struggled with an 18-year-old woman who ambushed him from behind to steal his car. The woman was arrested later that night after a chase and now faces multiple charges, including aggravated murder.

Although he wasn’t officially working that night, Officer Bartek died in the line of duty because he used his police training to try to subdue his assailant, city officials determined.

He is survived by his mother, brother, twin sister, and extended family.

Kaia LaFay Grant
Springdale Police Department
End of watch: March 21, 2020

On Aug. 23, 2019, Officer Grant and a co-worker, Detective Ritchy Tuazon, ventured an hour north to Yellow Springs for a day focused on photography and mountain biking, hobbies they shared.

Officer Grant was fairly new to both. She had a brand-new mountain bike and a new riding outfit with matching helmet, but her love for adventure had been lifelong.

“She was a natural,” said Tuazon, a veteran mountain biker. He described one close encounter with a tight S-curve when Officer Grant was leading the way down a 13-mile trail.

“She’s going at great speed, and I’m thinking, ‘Oh no, she’s going to hit that tree,’” he recalled. “Moments before, she slams on the brakes, keeps her sightline. Dirt and leaves kick up — I wish I’d been recording it. But as soon as Kaia meets the tree, she plants her foot at the base and stops for one long second.

“Have you ever seen those people on skateboards and BMX bikes where they jump on a rail and freeze, and they hop off and they’re back in control? That’s exactly what she did. She had the skills of someone who had been riding for years.”

Officer Grant had a blast that day, and she and Tuazon talked about repeating such outings. “I’m going to get better and keep up with you on those hills,” Tuazon remembers her saying.

Setting goals and looking ahead were habits for Officer Grant. In college at William & Mary University in Virginia, where she majored in economics, Grant interned at the U.S. Senate, where she worked with, among others, now-President Joe Biden. She planned to go into politics.

She joined the Springdale PD after graduating and working with at-risk kids in Cincinnati. “Instead of going into the military and then going into politics, like many do, she wanted to serve the community versus serving in war,” Tuazon said.

Officer Grant wanted to get a master’s degree and, as a devoted pet owner, talked about opening a gym for humans and attached dog park, said Officer Michael DiStefano, a colleague who had attended the State Highway Patrol Academy with her.

“Sometimes this job defines people; it’s what they live and breathe,” DiStefano said. “Kaia was a cop, but it wasn’t her identity. She had her hand in so many things.”

The proud gearhead — “if it was a hobby that had gear and she could create a budget for it, she was gonna do it,” Tuazon said — spoke Spanish and Mandarin. She knew a martial art and how to use her weight in a tussle, and she was proficient with firearms. She was reserved, but her smile could light up a room.

“And in eight years, I never once saw her lose her temper,” DiStefano said. “Calm breeds calm in our world, which is why I think people never really tested her that way. It’s just that sense she put out there when she showed up at a scene.”

He recalled a night where the department was on alert for a possible suicidal person. A cellphone ping returned an unusually large search area, but after fruitlessly hunting, officers were close to giving up. That’s when Officer Grant found a fairly hidden parking garage basement. She called DiStefano for backup, and inside they located the woman. She had passed out in a car with a garden hose funneling exhaust inside.

“She would have died within a short time if Kaia hadn’t found her location, but she survived,” DiStefano said. “And Kaia was so humble about it. We were giving her a bunch of ‘atta-girls,’ and she just shrugged it off, like, ‘Hey, it’s my job.’”

Both DiStefano and Tuazon said fellow officers liked working alongside Officer Grant when there was trouble, and she skillfully handled domestic situations and mediating disputes.
“She was very good at being able to calm the victim,” Tuazon said. “And children just were able to communicate with her.”

Officer Grant served Springdale for seven years and seven months until, on March 21, 2020, a nearby department requested help pursuing a man wanted for breaking into a home and pistol whipping an occupant.

On Interstate 275, Officer Grant and a colleague were preparing to put down tire-deflation devices when the chase reached them. The fleeing driver veered from his course to target the officers and struck Officer Grant. The 33-year-old was air-lifted to a local hospital, but she didn’t make it.

The wanted man shot himself but survived and was set to plead guilty to aggravated murder.

After some time passed, Tuazon, who owns a photography business, reached out to the mother of a young man whose senior photos Officer Grant had helped take. They all had had such a good experience, he just wanted the mother to know what happened.

“I’m so fortunate to have met her,” the mother told him. “Kaia shed such light and energy, and it’s sad to lose such a beautiful person.”

“She got it exactly right,” Tuazon said.

Officer Grant, a native of Wyoming, Ohio, is survived by her mother, Gina R. Mobley; father and step-mother, Kevin and Lekesha Grant; several stepbrothers; many extended family members; dear friend Joe Haugh; her brothers and sisters in blue; and her beloved Basenji, a hunting dog she drove all the way to Georgia to pick up, whom she had named Athen.

Anthony Dia
Toledo Police Department
End of watch: July 4, 2020

At age 26, Officer Anthony Dia was still a young man, but he had already found a clarity of purpose that eludes many who live decades longer.

The officer, a married father of two young sons, dedicated his life to loving his family, following his faith and protecting his city.

“I lived a fulfilling life, and I accomplished all anyone could ask for,” Officer Dia wrote a couple of months before he was killed.

That letter, “My Final Words and Will to My Family,” came during Ramadan, a holy month observed by Muslims through fasting, prayer and reflection.

He had a sense that he was going to be leaving soon, explained Imam Sayed Al-Qazwini, founder of the Islamic Institute of America in Dearborn Heights, Michigan, which Officer Dia’s family sometimes attended.

“Every day I put on the uniform,” Officer Dia wrote, “it was with the intention to protect the innocent and the weak in my community from evil.”

He would have celebrated two years with the Toledo Police Department a couple of weeks after he died and had previously spent two years as an officer for the Mercy Health System Police.

“Anthony was the example of a fine officer,” his supervisor, Lt. Joe Trudeau, told Police Chief George Kral. “He never — and I can honestly say the word never — had anything negative to say about anyone or anything.”

Chief Kral read those comments at Officer Dia’s funeral, describing the man as a consummate professional who always took time to greet people on the streets, especially children. In fact, two hours before he was killed, the officer stopped at a gas station where he let a couple of kids sit in his patrol car and sound the siren. Their family snapped photos — the last taken of the officer.

“If I had 50 Dias on my shift, I would take them all, knowing that everything would be done right and we would be a happy shift,” Chief Kral quoted Lt. Trudeau as saying. “I’m proud to have served with him.”

The officer graduated from police academies twice, first at Owens Community College and later the Toledo Police Department’s own academy. Mayor Wade Kapszukiewicz pointed out that Dia had chosen to become a law enforcement officer during troubled times for the profession.

“He knew what was going on in this country, and he chose to do it anyway because of his loyalty and his love for our community,” Kapszukiewicz said.

Outside of the job he loved, Officer Dia focused on his large family. In addition to his wife and sons, ages 6 and 8, he had a wealth of siblings, cousins and other relatives, including in Lebanon, from which his ancestors emigrated years ago. Officer Dia was born in Toledo.

The officer enjoyed wrestling and coaching the sport; Brazilian jiujitsu; cheering on the Los Angeles Rams; and animals, especially pit bulls.

He met his wife, Jayme, at a concert when he was 16. In the letter to his family, the graduate of Bedford High School called her the love of his life and apologized for not saying it more often; he also encouraged his sons to be proud of their religion.

“For all non-Muslims, look at the example of Officer Anthony Dia when you think of a Muslim in your mind,” Imam Al-Qazwini said at the funeral. “When you think of Islam, think of this man who gave his life on the Fourth of July to defend the values of the United States.”

On the evening that he was killed, Officer Dia answered a call to check on an intoxicated man in a Home Depot parking lot, the site of an informal car show. The officer arrived expecting to help the man.

Instead, the man refused Officer Dia’s overture and walked away, pulling a handgun and firing over his shoulder as he went. The bullet hit an area of the officer’s chest not covered by his protective vest; still, Officer Dia managed to fire back.

“He did everything perfectly,” Chief Kral said. “He positioned his cruiser in a tactical position. He approached the suspect in the correct manner, and the tragedy happened anyway.”
The shooter rushed into nearby woods and fatally shot himself.

Officer Dia’s last words were to the dispatcher: “Tell my family I love them.”

He is survived by his wife of eight years, Jayme; sons Younes and Maytham; father, Younes “Tony” Dia, and stepmother, Jehan Dia; mother, Gina Long, and stepfather, Frank Hoover; five siblings and step-siblings; many more family members; and his brothers and sisters in blue.

James M. Skernivitz
Cleveland Division of Police
End of watch: Sept. 3, 2020

Detective James “Skern” Skernivitz didn’t grow up dreaming about becoming a police officer. He ended up applying for a job with the Cleveland Police Division as part of a favor for a friend.

According to a story told by his wife, Kristen Kilburg, and relayed by a chaplain at the detective’s funeral, a buddy from Pittsburgh was planning a trip to Cleveland in 1998, hoping to land a job with CPD. But he was nervous about driving downtown.

Skernivitz made an offer: “Come to my house, and I’ll take you.” Rather than just sitting in his car and waiting, he decided to take the civil service exam, too. After all, he liked helping people.

“On his application, for reasons for becoming a police officer, he wrote: ‘I want to protect the city I grew up in and make it safe,’” Chief Calvin Williams said at the funeral. “Jimmy also wrote, ‘I want to work as part of a team in doing that.’

“He was a consummate team player,” the chief said of Skern, who went on to graduate from the division’s police academy in June 1998 and serve in the 2nd, 3rd and 4th neighborhood policing districts. As a detective in 2013, he joined the Gang Impact Unit, which achieved dramatic reductions in violence and guns on Cleveland’s East Side.

“Jim wouldn’t be happy with all of this attention,” his wife said via Father Doug Brown, the chaplain who led Detective Skernivitz’s funeral. “He was a guy who liked to be in the background, but he helped everyone else shine.”

Although he did not seek recognition throughout his 22-year career, Detective Skernivitz earned it. He was recognized dozens of times with special commendations and service medals for taking violent criminals off the streets – and pleased community members wrote to thank him.

“What he did out there for our city was to try to lift — not individuals, not neighborhoods, not groups — but an entire city to a higher, more noble life,” Chief Williams said.
The career that Detective Skernivitz hadn’t aspired to turned out to be one he never wanted to leave, even as he approached 25 years of service, his wife said through a letter that was read aloud at the funeral.

On Sept. 2, 2020, he was sworn in as an FBI task force officer for Operation Legend, a federal effort to fight crime surging across the country.

“As a veteran officer, he didn’t have to take on that dangerous mission,” U.S. Attorney General William Barr said at Detective Skernivitz’s funeral. “He could have let someone else do it, especially given the risks to police officers these days. But once again, he volunteered.”

The detective was a policeman’s policeman who rarely took a day — or night — off work.

About 10 p.m. the day after he joined the task force, he was meeting with one of his informants, Scott Dingess, in an unmarked car in Cleveland’s Stockyards neighborhood. Three males — a 15-yearold, a 17-year-old and an 18-year-old — approached and shot the detective and Dingess, apparently hoping to rob them.

Both died that night. Detective Skernivitz, 53, had three children, the youngest 19; Dingess was 50 and a father of five. Compounding the tragedy, another Cleveland policeman, Officer Nicholas Sabo, a seven-year veteran and 39-year-old father of four, took his own life a few hours later while off-duty.

The three shooters have been charged and await trial.

Detective Skernivitz had protected his family from realizing the danger that he faced every day, his wife said via the chaplain. “At home, he was just Dad — no frills, no fanfare, just Dad.”

He was a master prescriber of nicknames who enjoyed concerts, sporting events and travel. He worked as an usher and in security at Progressive Field, Rocket Mortgage FieldHouse and other venues in northeastern Ohio. A favorite part-time gig was providing security at presidential rallies throughout the country.

Detective Skernivitz played softball for many years in East Coast tournaments with the Steel City Enforcers, and every year he and his brother, Greg, journeyed to Las Vegas to watch the Police Softball World Series. Their first stop was always the Double Down Saloon for a drink and some ’80s heavy metal.

The Brecksville resident is survived by his wife of 23 years; their children, daughter Bayleigh and son Peyton; his son Matthew Collecchi; his mother, Sandy; his brother, Greg; many other family members and friends; and his brothers and sisters in blue.

Adam McMillan
Hamilton County Sheriff’s Office
End of watch: Oct. 23, 2020

One decorated Christmas tree was never enough for Cpl. McMillan.

Five seemed more appropriate to the man who routinely embraced joy in his daily life and spread it to others. One of his holiday-decorating goals seemed to be outdoor lights visible for blocks, and he relished watching vehicles slow down in front of his home so the humans inside could gape.

Cpl. McMillan loved arranging his decorations just so, giving gifts and, most of all, bringing family and friends together for Christmas. Halloween received a similar treatment.

The mischievous, adventurous corporal also loved bicycle riding, primitive camping, traveling, pencil drawing, collecting family and World War II memorabilia, ribbing friends and playing practical jokes. He appreciated history, traditions, Jeeps, animals — he took allergy medicine so he could keep pets — and beautiful fall days.

“He would call me before we would start work and be like: ‘Jason, today’s going to be a good day. It’s going to be beautiful out,’” said Cpl. Jason Hovekamp, one of Cpl. McMillan’s best friends and a co-worker at the sheriff ’s office.

“Every birthday, he would invite me over and cook meals and have presents,” Cpl. Hovekamp recalled at the funeral. “Well, I was one of the first deputies to have the new Charger in the fleet. We both loved that car. He made me a cake that looked just like that police cruiser, with lights on it and my car number. Just to see his face light up — he was so proud of that cake.

“I asked how long it took, and he said, ‘Oh, only like six or seven hours’ — like that was no big deal.”

Cpl. McMillan brought the same sense of ease and big heart to his 19 years at the sheriff ’s office.

“Adam was a leader and a professional dedicated to providing service to his community,” then-Sheriff Jim Neil said at the funeral in October 2020. “He had an endless desire to do his job to the best of his abilities.”

The corporal was recognized four times with sheriff’s commendations — for heroic efforts, saving lives and arresting criminals — and residents had written the sheriff’s office dozens of times to thank him for his help.

“Being a deputy sheriff did not define Adam,” Cpl. Hovekamp said. “But his undeniable character and qualities led to him being a decorated and celebrated deputy sheriff.”

His family and friends described Cpl. McMillan as naturally considerate. He made it a priority to be a gentleman, always thanked dispatchers and believed in the Golden Rule. He was kind not just to his family and friends, or even just to the public that he was paid to help.

“He was the kind of guy who asked the person in the drive-thru window how their day was going, and he always left them with a ‘thank you’ and a ‘have a good one,’ ” said Pastor Tim Kufeldt at Cpl. McMillan’s funeral. “He was best friends with his wife, Emily, before they married, during their marriage and even after their divorce.”

Cpl. McMillan took care of elderly neighbors and once purchased a new backpack for a homeless man he had noticed living under an overpass. The officer stocked that bag with items that would make living on the streets easier, Cpl. Hovekamp said.

The Rev. Steve Angi, a Cincinnati police chaplain, said that the corporal used his role with the Hamilton County Sheriff’s Office as a way to channel his kind-heartedness.

“The field of law enforcement was a natural outlet for his desire to help people,” Angi said at the funeral. “God gave Adam the outgoing personality, physical strength, intelligence, good judgment, passion and stick-to-it-iveness needed to be successful in law enforcement. It was his calling to protect us, to help us laugh … and lift us up.”

McMillan, a 2000 graduate of the Great Oaks police academy and a fourth-generation law enforcement officer, was valedictorian of his class at the corrections academy he also attended. He aced traffic-accident reconstruction school in 2014 and scored almost perfectly on the promotional exam that made him a corporal in 2017.

At the time of his death, Cpl. McMillan was a trained flight observer for the aviation unit and was assigned to the traffic safety division. On Oct. 8, 2020, he was on patrol when he was involved in a chain-reaction crash at the intersection of Eight Mile Road and Beechmont Avenue. Cpl. McMillan’s cruiser crashed into a bus.

The 42-year-old officer suffered a serious head injury and spent two weeks unconscious and in critical condition before succumbing to his injuries. He was an organ donor.

“I’ve never met anybody in my entire life who was as selfless as Adam was,” his brother-in-law, Jon Hilgeford, said at the funeral. “It’s not a surprise that he was an organ donor and that he gave life with his death. His passing, as tragic as it was, allowed others to live.”

Cpl. McMillan is survived by his father, Kevin McMillan; mother and stepfather, Rebecca and John Schweizer; sister, Golf Manor Police Officer Erin McMillan, and Hilgeford; many more family members and friends; and his law enforcement family.

Dale J. Woods
Colerain Township Police Department
End of watch: Jan. 7, 2019

When Dale Woods was a boy, he wanted to be a policeman and a firefighter. He grew up to be both, and more.

“ ‘To serve and protect’ was more than a motto to him,” Colerain Township Police Chaplain James Love said at Officer Woods’ funeral. “Let me count the ways in which he served: He served as a firefighter with Colerain, a fire investigator with North College Hill. He was a police officer with North College Hill; worked with dispatch; a police officer with Lincoln Heights; worked with animal control; a firearms instructor; and, as a Colerain police officer, he was part of the honor guard, bike patrol, quick response team, missing person team, SWAT team and a detective.…

“He only got jobs in which he was serving other people,” the chaplain said. “That’s all he ever chose.”

And the residents of the communities that Officer Woods served were grateful. Just a couple of hours before the father of three was fatally struck by a pickup truck, a man called to thank the officer for saving his baby the previous summer from a locked and sweltering car.

“When we hire police officers, we often say, ‘Bring me a good person, and I can turn him into a good cop,’” said Chief Mark Denney of the Colerain Police Department, where Officer Woods worked since 2003. “But every once in a while, you run into a natural police officer.

“You run into someone who was born with bravery, common sense, knowing how to talk to people with respect and how to handle stressful situations without having to be taught. Those are the ones who run into gunfire, into burning buildings and run through brick walls for people they’ve never met before.

“That was Dale Woods.”

The chief ’s description isn’t hyperbole. In September 2018, Officer Woods actually did run into a burning building to save a blind resident, who had assumed she would never escape. Officer Woods was honored with the Colerain Police Department’s Lifesaving Award for that act. His record includes multiple medals of valor, letters of commendation and awards of appreciation.

He was the kind of officer who saved lives.

“He was also the kind of man,” Chief Denney said, “who would place brand new police officers in his car and make them listen to the most God-awful music ever created as he trained them to be cops.”

Music was more than an amusing torture device for Officer Woods, who was a drummer. He played with two drum and bugle corps, Cincinnati Tradition and Limited Edition; at John Wesley United Methodist Church; and with the bands at Colerain middle and high schools.

In his spare time, Officer Woods ran an auto-detailing business, Details by Dale, and enjoyed bodybuilding and golf. He was reportedly so good at the latter that he was regarded as a “professional” at Cincinnati’s Clovernook Country Club, where he was a member.

“To say Dale just enjoyed golf is an understatement,” Chaplain Love said.

Yet the officer wasn’t one to brag about his skills or feats, or those of his children — Trinity, Hallie and Collin — of whom he was especially proud.

“I had the privilege of knowing Dale for 32 years,” Chief Denney said at Officer Woods’ funeral. “In the first two or three years, we ran in different circles and weren’t what I would consider friends. He said maybe 10 or 15 words to me.

“But then I look back, and the remaining 29 years, I’m not sure he said much more than that,” Chief Denney continued. “But you never doubted his friendship. He had a remarkable ability for gaining friendships and earning respect without saying very much.”

On Jan. 4, 2019, Officer Woods was quietly going about his job on a rainy night. He was placing cones on Colerain Avenue to direct traffic around an accident scene when a passing pickup struck him.

The 46-year-old officer was rushed to the University of Cincinnati Medical Center, where he died three days later. He was an organ donor, who in death saved a few more Cincinnati-area residents, according to the LifeCenter Organ Donor Network.

Officer Woods was survived by his children, Trinity, 22, Hallie, 19, and Collin, 15; his mother, Ann Woods (Rex Corn); girlfriend, Beckie Saylor; sister, Dori Marcotte; and many friends, other family members and fellow first responders.

“Dale lived a short life,” said Colerain Township Trustee Raj Rajagopol, a former deputy sheriff and friend of Officer Woods’. “But all the life he lived was for others, sacrificing.”

William L. Brewer Jr.
Clermont County Sheriff’s Office
End of watch: Feb. 2, 2019

Detective Bill Brewer loved his wife, loved his 8-year-old son and loved that his job centered on protecting people.

“He actually — it sounds cliché — but he truly enjoyed helping people,” said Detective Adam Bailey, who had been friends with Detective Brewer since both were seventh-graders. “He was just a normal guy trying to make a difference in society.”

Detective Brewer had been trying to make a difference since joining the Clermont County Sheriff ’s Office as a corrections officer in 1998. He became a deputy in 2006 and, in 2015, joined the Special Response Team, the office’s SWAT team. He saw that role as another way to be of assistance, to other officers and to people on perhaps the worst day of their lives.

“This would be the guy I would want to show up if my family members were in need,” Sheriff Steve Leahy said at the detective’s funeral.

Through the years, Detective Brewer was commended for actions such as finding a child lost in Stonelick State Park and catching a knife-wielding man who was chasing the daughter of a local police chief.

“Bill could always be counted on to do the right thing,” Sheriff Leahy said. “Knowing he was around just made me feel better.”

The detective’s personnel file was packed with thank-you notes from residents he’d helped, including an elderly man whose car was egged on a freezing-cold night. Brewer and his partner not only took a police report but also cleaned the man’s car.

“He was a huge team player, and he thought that everybody else should be a team player, too,” Detective Bailey said.

The cooperative attitude likely stemmed from Detective Brewer’s starring roles on his high school sports teams. At Williamsburg High School, the quarterback made the First Team All-District in 1993, 1994 and 1995 and broke school records for touchdown passes in a season (54) and passing yards in a season (2,046). He played four years of varsity basketball and, in baseball, made the All League team in 1994.

“Even though he had all kinds of sports accolades and records, he was humble,” said Detective Bailey, who played football with Brewer. “He didn’t flaunt it or act like he was better than anyone else.”

After high school, Brewer went on to play a year of football at Cumberland University in Kentucky before transferring to the University of Cincinnati and earning an associate degree. But when he became a father, he didn’t force his passion on his son.

“Braxton wasn’t big into playing sports, so that didn’t occupy their time,” Detective Bailey said.
“Bill and his family used their time to go out and make memories in different places – Gatlinburg, Disney World, state parks, water parks, museums. They were big on just creating experiences and making memories.”

Detective Brewer and his son collected Hot Wheels, and the whole family – including Brewer’s wife and Braxton’s mother, Jamie – had wide-ranging music tastes, with R&B and rap being their favorites. The detective liked any food he could put ketchup on and had a penchant for using the word “reference.” For example, Bailey recalled: “Reference yesterday’s conversation.”

As a stay-at-home mom, Jamie Brewer was there to capture the family adventures.
“She took thousands and thousands of pictures of them,” Detective Bailey said. “Their walls are covered, and that is so nice going to their house and seeing those pictures of all of them together.

“It was like God told her – you know, whispered to her: ‘Hey, Bill might not be around forever, so take as many pictures as you can.’ And she did.”

Their photos became all the more poignant after Detective Brewer, 42, was killed in an ambush.

On Feb. 2, 2019, a young man called 911 twice, first with a fake robbery report and then to say he was suicidal. The man fired his gun when deputies arrived at his apartment, prompting the SRT, including Detective Brewer, to respond.

When the man faked shooting himself, Detective Brewer and Lt. Nick DeRose entered the apartment, intending to give aid. That’s when the man shot through a wall, killing the detective and wounding the lieutenant (who has recovered and returned to work).

The shooter was sentenced to life in prison with no chance of parole.
Detective Brewer left behind Jamie Hensley Brewer, his wife of 13 years, and their son, Braxton; his parents, William Sr. and Angie Brewer; his brother, Michael Brewer; his parents-in-law, James and Mary Noll; several nieces and nephews; and his brothers and sisters in blue.

Jorge R. Del Rio
Dayton Police Department
End of watch: Nov. 7, 2019

At a career point when many officers have retired or are getting ready to, 55-year-old Detective Jorge Del Rio was working undercover and leading the charge while executing search warrants.

When he was fatally shot by drug suspects, the married father of five had been with Dayton police for almost 30 years, including 19 years assigned to a Drug Enforcement Administration task force. In that role, the detective had the same powers as a DEA agent, working undercover not only in his home city but throughout the United States.

As some of his colleagues put it: He was a true shadow warrior.

“He never shied away from difficult challenges or dangerous situations, serving on the front lines of our fight for justice and for our country,” Special Agent in Charge Keith Martin, who leads the region’s DEA teams, said at the detective’s funeral.

The undercover work of Detective Del Rio – a native of Mexico City raised by a single mom in East Chicago, Indiana – was so skilled, it was said to be unfair to bad guys, said Special Agent Steven Miller, who leads the DEA office in Dayton.

“In reality, the opposite was true as he had an uncommonly strong sense of justice and fairness,” Miller said at the funeral, illustrating his point with a story about a sting in which Detective Del Rio posed as a drug supplier (with simplified drug amounts).

“To ensure it was fair, Jorge and the case manager decided beforehand that Jorge would say (to the drug dealers), ‘Look, if you can only sell 1 kilogram, then take 1 kilogram. But if you can take 2 and that’s normal for you, then take 2,’” Miller said.

“This was an important gesture because the difference between taking 1 and 2 kilograms would effectively double the jail time for the suspect. Jorge explained that ‘Just because you can do something, doesn’t mean that it’s the right thing to do. The badge is only as good as the man or woman standing behind it.’”

During his career, Detective Del Rio was commended for acts that included saving a drowning 14-year-old who had driven into the Great Miami River; helping to arrest the man who shot and wounded Officer Timothy Reboulet in 1995; preventing the murder-for-hire of two people through a reverse sale of a firearm, a silencer and explosives; and recovering 7 kilos of cocaine, half a kilo of heroin and $200,000 in cash in a single case.

A poster that Del Rio kept on an office wall said, “Courage: Being scared to death but saddling up anyway.”

“He left a legacy of service and sacrifice to this noble profession that is rare even among the best of us,” Dayton Police Chief Richard Biehl said.

The detective was also funny, warmhearted and dedicated to his family.

“When he was not at work, he was with his family,” Chief Biehl said. “When he was at work, he spoke fondly about his family.”

He met his wife, Kathy, in 1986, when both worked at an Elder-Beerman’s department store. They went on to have five daughters: Ariel, Ericka, Veronica, Naya and Dana. Colleagues referred to the detective and his girls as Del Rio and the Del Rio-ettes. He used to proudly recount their achievements, including how they excelled when their father, a firearms enthusiast, taught them to shoot.

Friends said Detective Del Rio had an infectious laugh, incredible luck finding good parking spots and a love for sharing meals — or, as he liked to say, “breaking bread like a gentleman.” There was no fast food, no hurrying, no eating in the car.

On Nov. 7, 2019, Detective Del Rio died at Grandview Hospital, three days after being shot twice. He had been serving a search warrant at a Dayton residence and leading a group of officers down a stairway into a basement.

He left behind a wealth of admiring colleagues and friends as well as his family: his wife, Kathy, who is blind; daughters Ariel Del Rio Busch (Steven), Erica Hampton (Devin), Veronica Del Rio and Naya Del Rio; and granddaughters Aliyah Shafeek, Luna Hampton and Santana Busch. He was preceded in death by his mother, Beatriz Hernandez, and daughter Dana Shafeek.

Three men have been indicted on charges that carry the death penalty in Detective Del Rio’s death. As a result of the search warrant, officers seized 10 kilograms of fentanyl, more than 50 pounds of marijuana and $51,000 in cash.

Eric J. Joering
Westerville Division of Police
End of watch: Feb. 10, 2018

“Selfless” would be one way to describe Police Officer Eric J. Joering, said Guy Cerino, his good friend and fellow officer at the Westerville Division of Police. “Generous” would be another.

“It’s hard to try to say one thing about him or describe him in one word,” Cerino said. “To find that word — I can’t. It’s many.”

Joering was a guy who would bring in the best cuts of the deer he’d hunted to share with co-workers for dinner at the station. And a guy who drove 40 miles in the middle of the night to comfort Cerino after Cerino’s young son died of cancer.

“At work, if you came in and had a question, or you were working on a case and you needed his help, he always dropped what he was doing for you,” Cerino said.

He recalled one time in particular, when he himself was investigating a hit-skip suspect and Joering was a detective focused on crimes involving juveniles. Joering put aside his heavy workload, Cerino said, to help him decipher what a thick packet of cell-tower data showed about the suspect.

“Eric would give you the shirt off his back if you needed it; if you needed money, he’d give you money,” said Cerino, who was hired in 2001, the same year that Joering was. “And that was the kind of person he was.”

During his years at the division, Joering received dozens of commendations, including seven Exceptional Duty awards. One of the most notable came after he helped the FBI and police departments on both coasts recover $3 million worth of jewelry stolen from a vendor passing through Westerville.

Sgt. Tony Rudd, who supervised Joering in the detective bureau, called him an expert in police tactics and weapons. He helped Rudd choose a rifle and navigate the complicated, seven-month process of obtaining federal approval to carry it at work.

Joering also served as a training officer, a firearms trainer and a street cop. After his stint as a detective, he became a K9 officer partnered with a Belgian Malinois named Sam.

Working with police dogs was Joering’s dream job, former Westerville Police Chief Joe Morbitzer has said.

Joering, who lived with his family outside Centerburg, also loved hunting, four-wheeling, scuba diving and being outdoors. He and his wife, Jami, enjoyed spending time on their boat and going on double dates with Cerino and his wife. The Joerings’ three young daughters — Eva, Elena and Ella — can be called proud daddy’s girls.

“They’re at that age where doing anything with Dad intrigued them,” Cerino said. “So if Dad’s hunting, they were like, ‘I want to go hunting with Dad. I want to spend time with Dad.’”

In a thank-you video to the Westerville community in 2018, Jami described how Sam and the girls would pile onto Joering when he sat in his recliner in the evenings. The chair, she said, is still the favorite place to curl up for Sam, who has lived with the family since the Westerville Police Division retired him after Joering’s death.

“There’s nothing better than those three girls getting to be with that dog,” said Morbitzer, now superintendent of the Ohio Bureau of Criminal Investigation.

On Feb. 10, Joering and Police Officer Anthony P. Morelli were dispatched to a home on a domestic-violence call. After they were let in, a man opened fire. Both officers were hit and fired at the shooter, wounding him. Joering, 39, died at the scene.

Franklin County is seeking the death penalty for the shooter, who, as a felon, shouldn’t have had a gun.

Joering is survived by his wife and three daughters; his mother-in-law, Terri Seligman; his parents, Jim and Lillian Joering; his brother, Michael (Jen); his police family; and many friends.

Cerino attributes one of the best experiences he had with his son, Jaret, to the Joering family.

He had gone to the Joerings’ home to do something — maybe help refinish the basement or chop wood, he couldn’t recall — and the Joerings decided late in the afternoon to invite the rest of Cerino’s family to come from their Grove City home for dinner.

Cerino’s son, Jaret — about 3 years old at the time and battling cancer — begged for a ride on Officer Joering’s four-wheeler. “I wasn’t going to say no,” Cerino said. “And Eric wasn’t going to say no.”

Cerino put Jaret in front of him and would press the throttle to make it get up and go, and let off, and press the throttle and let off. Jaret couldn’t get enough.

“At that moment in time, our son had no cares in the world,” Cerino said. “I’ll never forget that day, because of Eric, and I still thank him for it. … He was very generous.”

Anthony P. Morelli
Westerville Division of Police
End of watch: Feb. 10, 2018

The countdown to retirement was underway for Officer Anthony “Tony” Pasquale Morelli and four of his fellow officers at the Westerville Division of Police.

The five had started on the same day in 1988. They’d gone through the State Highway Patrol Academy together. They’d vacationed together. They’d joked that their kids would grow up to marry each other. And they’d all signed on to the deferred retirement program.

Using an app on his cellphone, Sgt. Tony Rudd was counting off the days, hours and even the seconds until April 27, 2021.

“The ‘Fab Five’ were all going to go out and have one giant party,” Rudd said.

Then Feb. 10 happened.

“I remember looking at that app, and it made me sick,” Rudd said. “So I deleted it for good.

“It took tragedy,” he continued, “to wake me up to the fact that — you know what? — tomorrow’s not guaranteed. We all need to make the most of every day.”

By all accounts, Officer Morelli always did.

“Since 1988, any story that I have told — the best times that I’ve had as an adult — inevitably Tony Morelli is part of that story,” said retired Training Officer Dave King, who started a month before the Fab Five and was close friends with them.

Morelli, a father of two, loved his family; the Massillon Tigers (and sharing how he’d played football there with OSU star Chris Spielman); baseball (his team was the Boston Red Sox); AC/DC (he’d play air guitar to “You Shook Me All Night Long”); and working out.

He joined charity runs and races such as the Warrior Dash with his daughter, Beth; wife, Linda; and anyone else he could coax into joining him. He enjoyed golfing with his son, Chris.

“My favorite memories are tailgating with Tony at Ohio State football games,” said Officer Jeff Dixon. “That was his favorite place to be in the world early on a Saturday morning.

“He would always welcome anybody who wanted to come. They always had the food and the drinks and just wanted you to show up. Wouldn’t take a penny from anybody.”

Dixon got to know Morelli when they worked first shift together, after Morelli’s kids grew up and he started volunteering to work on Christmas. That meant Dixon and other officers got to spend the holiday with their young children.

Morelli also worked special duty at the Westerville Library, taught self-defense classes for women, and spent a few years as a school resource officer. He was well-liked in Westerville, where he also lived.

In his 30 years with the police division, he was voted officer of the year in 2003 and 2012, was honored with a Medal of Valor and received many other awards.

One resident wrote to thank Morelli for saving 10 baby ducks from a sewer. Another wouldn’t have sent a thank-you: The 80-year-old woman got annoyed when, after a well-being check, Morelli bought her groceries because she didn’t have any food. She gave him a hard time for picking out sliced turkey.

Colleagues enjoyed working with Morelli, and not just for the fun.

“Especially when we were young, everybody wanted to catch the bad guy,” King said. “So if there was a robbery, no one wanted to go to the scene and catch the paper on it, because that’s not fun. But Tony would always step up and do the right thing” and take on the less exciting parts of the job, such as writing the report.

King recounted how Morelli memorized every Westerville street, even ones in odd corners, when they were new to the job.

“He never wanted to be the guy who didn’t know the answer.”

Morelli’s friends said he could be critical of his bosses’ decisions.

“I can’t tell you how many arguments we got into at roll calls, and I had to clear the room because he and I were going at it,” Rudd said. “Then we’d hang out together. It was like having a brother.”

Three days after Morelli’s 54th birthday, on Feb. 10, he and K9 Officer Eric Joering were dispatched to a home where a gunman ambushed them. Both officers were hit and fired back, wounding the shooter.

Morelli died at Ohio State University’s Wexner Medical Center.

“Tony was the second guy through the doorway that day, and he probably could have retreated out of there,” Rudd said. “But there’s no way — that’s not Tony.”

Morelli is survived by Linda, his wife of almost 29 years; Elizabeth, his daughter, who married Danny Frank in June 2018; Christopher, his son; his parents, Anthony and Carolyn Morelli; brothers David (Ramneet) and Michael; nieces and nephews Sukhjit, Jasjit, Simi and Lucas; and friends in Westerville and Massillon.

“He was full of life, and every day was something special to him,” Rudd said. “The thing is, you don’t realize how much you’ve lost until he’s gone.”

Mathew J. Mazany
Mentor Police Department
End of watch: June 24, 2018

Patrolman Mathew “Mat” Mazany was a throwback kind of cop.

He didn’t believe in writing long, extravagant police reports, or in being politically correct every second of his shift. He’d tell you how it was, and then he’d move on.

“When I say Mat was an old-school cop, I don’t call into question his ability or knowledge to do the job,” retired Mentor Police Sgt. Scott Tkach, who supervised Mazany for six years, said at his funeral.

“He knew what he was doing, and he did it well. He just did it a little bit different from most of us.”

Police work was in Mazany’s genes. His father was a police officer for 50 years in the Army and, later, in Maple Heights. From a young age, Mazany knew he wanted to follow in his dad’s footsteps.

“If you knew Mat, Mat would never fight for himself when we were in school,” his best friend, Jamie Bassell, said at the funeral. “But if someone else was getting in trouble or someone else was getting bullied, Mat was the first one to step in. That’s the kind of person he was.”

The Mentor resident could also be charming, and his sense of humor cracked up friends and family members.

He was a devoted family man described by his son, also named Mat, as a nerd of sorts.

“Star Wars, Marvel, Transformers, ‘Metal Gear’ — he loved it all,” his son, 20 at the time, said at his father’s funeral.

The two were known to discuss the politics of the Clone Wars from Star Wars, and Officer Mazany’s ringtone played the introduction to the video game “Metal Gear Solid.”

Of course, it’s easy to see that a big portion of Officer Mazany’s attraction to these “nerd” games and movies was spending time with his son.

The elder Mazany also loved cigars, sports cars, his motorcycle and his wife of 22 years, Lisa. And he loved being a cop and working with his fellow officers in the Cleveland suburb of Mentor.

In his 14 years with the department, Mazany worked 12-hour midnight shifts. He was honored with the department’s Exceptional Service Award, and Mentor residents had written the department about his professionalism and compassion.

“Mentor was a safer place and the Mentor PD was a better police department because of Mat,” Tkach said.

Early on June 24, 2018, a Mentor police officer had pulled over a person wanted in another jurisdiction, and Officer Mazany, 41, arrived to assist. As he began to approach the vehicle, a Jeep struck him and drove off.

He was rushed to a nearby hospital but didn’t survive.

The driver of the Jeep was located a few hours later. The man — who, tests showed, had alcohol, heroin and fentanyl in his system — was charged with second-degree aggravated vehicular homicide, among other counts.

Besides his wife and son, Mazany is survived by his father, Michael S. Mazany; siblings, Michael J. Mazany (Danica) and Cindy Bradshaw; nephew, Alexander Devine; niece, Ashley Derda; friends; and his brothers in blue.

“His love was truly unconditional,” Bassell said. “It really pains me that Mat won’t be able to watch his son grow into a man. He’ll never have that drink with him for his 21st birthday.”

Vu X. Nguyen
Cleveland Division of Police
End of watch: July 6, 2018

To understand what kind of man Police Officer Vu Nguyen was, consider this story, which doesn’t even center on him:

The Cleveland Police Athletic League throws an annual Christmas party to treat thousands of children to games, gifts and lunch. Nguyen had volunteered every year, so, for the organizers, the gathering on Dec. 1, 2018 — the first without him — took on a somber note.

But it didn’t go off without a Nguyen.

The officer’s 15-year-old daughter, Kayla, a high-school sophomore, got up early on that Saturday and spent eight hours straight helping children pick out gifts in the toy tent.

“Not one complaint,” said Cleveland Police Sgt. Jennifer Ciaccia, who went through the police academy with Officer Nguyen and lives next door to the family. “Kayla’s a lot like her dad in that respect. She likes to be able to make somebody smile.”

Nguyen’s mission in life was to make others smile, especially his wife, Holli, and their two daughters — Maya is seven years younger than Kayla. The girls soaked up his selflessness and his positive outlook.

“Literally all he wanted was for his family to be happy,” Ciaccia said. “But he also somehow managed to touch so many people’s lives and make a difference by being himself and being present and engaged.”

The Avon resident spent 20 years working the streets for the Cleveland Police Department. He was a popular officer, with commendations in his file including a Medal of Heroism and a special thanks from the FBI’s Joint Terrorism Task Force.

Nguyen took police tactics seriously, just as he did the people he protected.

Detective Aaron Reese, Nguyen’s partner for more than six years, said he was the kind of officer who, if he was called to a single mom’s home and found the refrigerator low on food, would go buy the family groceries using his own money.

In fact, the Nguyen family dog was a rescue Nguyen had found — sick and abandoned in an empty house — while on patrol.

With animals and people alike, Nguyen shared his big heart.

“It’s funny, because he made me take the sergeant’s exam,” Reese recalled. “I really had no desire to take the test, but he made me sign up for the prep course. … I took it, and here I am very close to getting promoted — and it’s all because of him. He was always looking out for me.”

Nguyen was known around his neighborhood for passing out popsicles and organizing games involving 20 or so children at the local pool.

“He was like a dad to everybody’s kids,” Ciaccia said.

The officer also loved to eat and loved to take his family on vacations.

Nguyen was one of 14 brothers and sisters who have spread throughout the country, providing excellent vacation opportunities. The family emigrated from Vietnam to the Cleveland suburb of Lakewood in 1975, when Vu was 5 years old. His family called him the fun sibling, and the strong one.

Which is why, in part, his death at age 50 came as such a shock.

On July 2, 2018, Nguyen collapsed in 90-degree heat during a canine-officer training exercise. In large part due to the exertion, he ended up suffering organ failure; he was put on life support and died four days later, on July 6, at Cleveland Clinic.

Nguyen is survived by Holli, to whom he was married for almost 18 years; daughters Kayla and Maya; siblings Tam (Ken), Phuong (Trung), Van (Linh), Hang (Larry), Hai (Terri), Son (Nancy), Nga (Thuy), Phong (My-Lan), Huyen, Lan (Le), Mai (John), Truc (Sulaiman) and Thao (Kekoa); and more than 30 nieces and nephews. He was preceded in death by a young son, Devin Vu Nguyen, and his mother and father, a former police chief in Saigon.

“I would hope people just remember Vu as the guy who would give anything for anybody,” Ciaccia said. “He was completely selfless.”